Skip to main content

The NaMo Story



Book Review
Author: Kingshuk Nag
Pblisher: Roli Books, Delhi (2013)
Pages: 188       Price: Rs 295

Politics, like administration, is much about managing people.  While an administrator usually has to deal with people of a particular kind or profession, a politician has to deal with people of all kinds.  Dealing with people of all kinds requires a special art or skill.  Can that skill be described as ‘a criminal mind controlled by a superficial legal framework’?

This was the first thought that struck me as I put aside Kinshuk Nag’s biography of Narendra Modi which I borrowed from a student of mine.  Nag does not describe Modi as a self-controlled criminal.  He quotes an anonymous officer who had served in Modi’s intelligence set-up, “He (Modi) is well versed in Chanakya niti and the techniques of saam, daam, dand, bhed (equality, enticement, punishment, and sowing dissension) and uses them to good effect.”

It is precisely such people who become successful political leaders.  Especially in a state whose people are predominantly merchants.  Every Gujarati wants to be a trader.  No Gujarati wants to be in the police or the army.  Gujaratis are not a martial race.  The mercantile classes have a superficial approach to relationships.  They can smile at the devil or their own potential killer provided the latter are good customers.  Such people, however, suffer from a sense of insecurity.  Hence they need some henchmen at their side equipped with a machine gun.  Narendra Modi emerged as that henchman of the mercantile Gujarati.

But people of other states don’t suffer from such insecurity problems.  Hence NaMo’s machine guns won’t be popular in those states.  That’s why Modi had to change his image as the Hindu warrior to “Mahatma Modi” in the recent years when Prime Ministerial ambitions raised their natural heads in his genes.  He conducted sadbhavana yatras and fasts in order to woo the minority communities, particularly the Muslims.  But people are not as foolish as Modi imagines them to be.  Hence his histrionic yatras and fasts didn’t yield much political harvest.  Moreover, he realised the dilemma whose horns he had embraced unwittingly:  If he goes out of his way to woo the minorities, he may lose his popularity in Gujarat.  If he doesn’t, he may never sit on the chair occupied for long by a “Maun Mohan Singh”.

Nag’s book ends with Modi’s voyage to China (Nov 2011) where he was welcomed in the National Hall of People “where heads of states of national government are normally received.”   Modi is also trying to establish strong links with Canada and the USA.  In the final chapter we are reminded that NaMo’s new mask will be that of the Mahatma. 

The book is interesting to read.  But it remains a mere journalistic approach to biography.  Nag is a journalist with the Times of India.  The Times of India has a unique way of trivialising anything and also commercialising anything.  Nag has not commercialised NaMo’s biography though he has approached it in a very superficial way.  Is it because Mr Modi has nothing deep within him?  It can’t be.  Because he wouldn’t have become what he is unless there is something within even if that something be diabolic.  Nag has not explored that something.  Nag also doesn’t tell us much about Modi’s childhood and family background except that he was born in a low caste family as the son of a tea vendor at Vadnagar railway station.

The book does not inspire us in any way.  Maybe Narendra Modi cannot inspire anyone much.  But I’m sure even the devil can be made inspiring by a good writer.  Read Milton’s Paradise Lost, if you don’t believe me.  I think Nag should have probed the depths of Modi’s psyche instead of merely presenting the history of the man and his work from a journalist’s point of view.  


Comments

  1. yesterday,hearing the one-on-one interview of Uma Bharti in Sidhi Baat,She was asked ,Why Modi is growing popular?
    She said,"It is the insecurity and lack of governance of UPA II which has haunted the people of India and In search of a bold and powerful leader people of India are liking him very much."It wouldn't be wrong to say that there are many states who have registered rapid development and many leaders who have won years after years say,Naveen Pattnayak.

    NIce post . :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True, Modi is capable of giving the security feeling that people long for. He has a macho personality which attracts not only the Gujaratis. If he suppresses his communal feelings and focuses on genuine development (development of all irrespective of caste, creed...), he has a fair chance of occupying the top sea.

      Delete
    2. I am not his blind supported Tomichan but I have been forced to believe he has it in him coz I saw what Gujarat has become and the minority dominated areas are also well developed ..( i mean, i thought BJP will not bother) that was the only result ..Modi tookover Congress seats and many more from constituencies dominated by minorities .
      The way you said .,... he has lot of makeover to be done .. eradicate the fear of promoting riots yet again once and if he gets power and build that confidence !!
      I am developing an iniclination towards him being the PM .. to be honest .!!

      Delete
    3. If someone does good things I will never hesitate to accept that. The media has given us different images of Mr Modi. Even the development that he brought, according to many reports, is lop-sided. I can keep my fingers crossed.

      Delete
    4. Not all Gujaratis are cowards . There are Rajputs in Gujarat also . Rajputs are the most courageous people in India . Rajputs are the warrior caste found predominantly in the states of Rajasthan , Gujarat , Uttar Pradesh , Madhya Pradesh , Bihar , Haryana , Punjab etc . Many Rajputs of Gujarat have served in the army . The first Chief of staff of Indian Army was the Maharaja of Jamnagar . He was a Rajput by caste . His name was Rajendrasinhji Jadeja . He also fought in the second world war .

      Delete
    5. Not all Gujaratis are cowards . There are Rajputs in Gujarat also . Rajputs are the most courageous people in India . Rajputs are the warrior caste found predominantly in the states of Rajasthan , Gujarat , Uttar Pradesh , Madhya Pradesh , Bihar , Haryana , Punjab etc . Many Rajputs of Gujarat have served in the army . The first Chief of staff of Indian Army was the Maharaja of Jamnagar . He was a Rajput by caste . His name was Rajendrasinhji Jadeja . He also fought in the second world war .

      Delete
    6. Not all Gujaratis are cowards . There are Rajputs in Gujarat also . Rajputs are the most courageous people in India . Rajputs are the warrior caste found predominantly in the states of Rajasthan , Gujarat , Uttar Pradesh , Madhya Pradesh , Bihar , Haryana , Punjab etc . Many Rajputs of Gujarat have served in the army . The first Chief of staff of Indian Army was the Maharaja of Jamnagar . He was a Rajput by caste . His name was Rajendrasinhji Jadeja . He also fought in the second world war .

      Delete
  2. A good review saved me the trouble of reading it. Loved the quote
    The Times of India has a unique way of trivialising anything and also commercialising anything.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I neither love nor hate Modi. But the book in question is an obvious drivel. Mr Laloo Yadav would present a more natural pitch to his talents. Now, don't tell me Mr Yadav is not a potential PM candidate!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Why not, Uma? Mr Laloo Yadav drew the attention of the Harvard University!

      I think Nag wrote this book foreseeing Mr Modi becoming the PM or at least controversial in the process of trying to become.

      Delete
  4. Am not someone who drools much into politics or politicians...but must agree with your views...a good work makes the work of devil inspiring and whether anybody believes it or not...writers do bring out about the latent talent of a person...and presents in the way it should be presented...good or evil is only a matter of perception.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Politicians don't attract me too, Anjan. It's just that I happened to find a copy with a student... Moreover, I wanted to know what makes Modi tick?

      Delete
  5. Nice post Sir. Even I also want to know what makes Modi tick? Many people blindly say that only Modi can save India from this pathetic situation, but they don't have any answers on how? So, is it just a kind of myth? What to say? Intelligent people make fun of ignorant superstitious people, who used to wait for sometime whenever a cat would cross their way. But same intelligent people would go back home and would either try to show their respect towards the west direction or would light an agarbatti in front an idol.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You will have to wait till a good biographer comes along to write Modi's biography to know what really ticks him... As Felipe Fernandez-Armesto, historian, said, "Heroes do not make history; history makes heroes." The current situation in Gujarat has made Modi a hero. Does the current situation in India demand Modi as PM? If yes, history (of India) will make him a hero!

      Delete
  6. It seems rather political to comment .But i would rather vote Mr.Modi than to re-elect NCP. Stakes and expectations are high.Agree with the point that Mr.Modi uses all chanakya nitis to get work done.
    NANO project was cleverly bagged by Gujrat even when Maharashtra had all the resources.The kind of development seen in Gujrat is actually good in terms of industrial and technology.

    Then goes about the book sir i have read lot of articles and wiki pages about Mr.Modi .I read your replies to the comments.Would you suggest me to read this one? ..worth the time ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wouldn't recommend this book, Pavan, especially if you have read much about Modi already. The book doesn't go beyond journalistic articles. A biography should explore the personality, the deep cores of it, which this book fails to do.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ayodhya: Kingdom of Sorrows

T he Sarayu carried more tears than water. Ayodhya was a sad kingdom. Dasaratha was a good king. He upheld dharma – justice and morality – as best as he could. The citizens were apparently happy. Then, one day, it all changed. One person is enough to change the destiny of a whole kingdom. Who was that one person? Some say it was Kaikeyi, one of the three official wives of Dasaratha. Some others say it was Manthara, Kaikeyi’s chief maid. Manthara was a hunchback. She was the caretaker of Kaikeyi right from the latter’s childhood; foster mother, so to say, because Kaikeyi had no mother. The absence of maternal influence can distort a girl child’s personality. With a foster mother like Manthara, the distortion can be really bad. Manthara was cunning, selfish, and morally ambiguous. A severe physical deformity can make one worse than all that. Manthara was as devious and manipulative as a woman could be in a men’s world. Add to that all the jealousy and ambition that insecure peo...

Bharata: The Ascetic King

Bharata is disillusioned yet again. His brother, Rama the ideal man, Maryada Purushottam , is making yet another grotesque demand. Sita Devi has to prove her purity now, years after the Agni Pariksha she arranged for herself long ago in Lanka itself. Now, when she has been living for years far away from Rama with her two sons Luva and Kusha in the paternal care of no less a saint than Valmiki himself! What has happened to Rama? Bharata sits on the bank of the Sarayu with tears welling up in his eyes. Give me an answer, Sarayu, he said. Sarayu accepted Bharata’s tears too. She was used to absorbing tears. How many times has Rama come and sat upon this very same bank and wept too? Life is sorrow, Sarayu muttered to Bharata. Even if you are royal descendants of divinity itself. Rama had brought the children Luva and Kusha to Ayodhya on the day of the Ashvamedha Yagna which he was conducting in order to reaffirm his sovereignty and legitimacy over his kingdom. He didn’t know they w...

Liberated

Fiction - parable Vijay was familiar enough with soil and the stones it turns up to realise that he had struck something rare.   It was a tiny stone, a pitch black speck not larger than the tip of his little finger. It turned up from the intestine of the earth while Vijay was digging a pit for the biogas plant. Anand, the scientist from the village, got the stone analysed in his lab and assured, “It is a rare object.   A compound of carbonic acid and magnesium.” Anand and his fellow scientists believed that it must be a fragment of a meteoroid that hit the earth millions of years ago.   “Very rare indeed,” concluded the scientist. Now, it’s plain commonsense that something that’s very rare indeed must be very valuable too. All the more so if it came from the heavens. So Vijay got the village goldsmith to set it on a gold ring.   Vijay wore the ring proudly on his ring finger. Nobody, in the village, however bothered to pay any homage to Vijay’s...

Empuraan – Review

Revenge is an ancient theme in human narratives. Give a moral rationale for the revenge and make the antagonist look monstrously evil, then you have the material for a good work of art. Add to that some spices from contemporary politics and the recipe is quite right for a hit movie. This is what you get in the Malayalam movie, Empuraan , which is running full houses now despite the trenchant opposition to it from the emergent Hindutva forces in the state. First of all, I fail to understand why so much brouhaha was hollered by the Hindutvans [let me coin that word for sheer convenience] who managed to get some 3 minutes censored from the 3-hour movie. The movie doesn’t make any explicit mention of any of the existing Hindutva political parties or other organisations. On the other hand, Allahu Akbar is shouted menacingly by Islamic terrorists, albeit towards the end. True, the movie begins with an implicit reference to what happened in Gujarat in 2002 after the Godhra train burnin...

Empuraan and Ramayana

Maggie and I will be watching the Malayalam movie Empuraan tomorrow. The tickets are booked. The movie has created a lot of controversy in Kerala and the director has decided to impose no less than 17 censors on it himself. I want to watch it before the jingoistic scissors find its way to the movie. It is surprising that the people of Kerala took such exception to this movie when the same people had no problem with the utterly malicious and mendacious movie The Kerala Story (2023). [My post on that movie, which I didn’t watch, is here .] Empuraan is based partly on the Gujarat riots of 2002. The riots were real and the BJP’s role in it (Mr Modi’s, in fact) is well-known. So, Empuraan isn’t giving the audience any falsehood as The Kerala Story did. Moreover, The Kerala Story maligned the people of Kerala while Empuraan is about something that happened in the faraway Gujarat quite long ago. Why are the people of Kerala then upset with Empuraan ? Because it tells the truth, M...