In yet another instance of
history’s inexorable vindictiveness, Allah was driven out of Prayagraj on 16
Oct 2018. Allahabad became Prayagraj with the single stroke of a pen. The pen
is mightier than the sword if it is wielded by a mighty hand. Might is what
matters. It is what mattered from time immemorial. Every war is born of
someone’s desire to impose himself, his might, on others. War can be in the
form of name changes.
Changing the
name of a place is to erase its history. Changing the name of a place is to
erase a whole people from that place. Place names, animal totems, dress colours
or styles – they can all be weapons of mass destruction. Nothing really changes
except names, totems and dresses. Crime rates don’t change. Poverty levels
don’t. Political corruption and chicanery don’t. Even after Allah wad driven
out, the state of Uttar Pradesh has remained
the same, if not became worse, on the various parameters that
determine social progress and cultural development. One thing changed, however:
dominance. One whole community became vassals instead of citizens. The ego of
another community was inflated.
Such
conquests as these – obtained by changing names, totems and dresses – do not
prove that all the people in the state share the phobia or hatred of the person
who brings about the changes.
I once
visited Allahabad before it became Prayagraj along with Maggie. It was in 2015.
The school in Delhi where Maggie and I were teaching was breathing its last,
thanks to the villainous changes imposed on the teachers and students by a
religious cult. We started looking out for other job opportunities and one of
the many schools which showed interest in appointing us on mutually acceptable
terms was Khelgaon
Public School [KPS] in Allahabad. The school was founded by Dr
U K Mishra, a biochemical engineer by profession, who takes immense interest in
school education with a unique focus on sports and games. It is one of the rare
schools in the country with an enormous indoor stadium that has all the
facilities for various games and sports.
The school
sent us free tickets from Delhi by an AC train to attend the interview. We
were accommodated in the room next to the Principal’s own residence. We were
treated royally. The school made its car available for us when we expressed a
desire to see the Triveni Sangam and requested for a taxi after the interview.
When chicken was served for lunch, we were surprised. Chicken in a school
founded and run by a Brahmin in UP? “We have a lot of athletes in our hostels
from various parts of the country,” the attendant explained. “They need healthy
diet.”
KPS was a
wonderful example of the inclusiveness contained in the ancient Indian wisdom
which taught that the whole world is a family: Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam.
You won’t
find that sort of inclusiveness in UP generally. A man who calls himself Yogi
became the state’s chief minister and any possibility for inclusiveness that
KPS had promised vanished instantly. What happened to the glorious vision of
the Upanishads which refused to differentiate even between the divine and the
human? Why is UP today just the opposite of what the profound Advaita
philosophy taught?
The answers are
obvious, of course. Yogi was reported to have delivered 34 communally
inflammatory speeches in the three months that preceded the recent state
assembly elections. He made more than 100 anti-Muslim comments or allusions in
his campaign speeches. He explicitly divided the state into 80 versus 20. Division.
Just the opposite of what the Upanishads taught. It was this Yogi who drove away Allah from Prayagraj.
What has all
that hatred achieved except political power? By subjugation of one section of
the state’s population? According to all available statistics, there is more
unemployment among youth in UP now than ever. The state’s GDP is crumbling. It
is number one in poverty index. The law-and-order situation is pathetic with
wayside lynching by ordinary people and legal killing by the police. The way
the pandemic was handled was disconcerting.
I loved Allahabad
and Dr U K Mishra. But I was only a one-day visitor. A flirt. It was good that
I didn’t take up the job there. The Yogi would have disillusioned me
irreparably. Now he reminds me of Kajal Ahmad, the Kurdish poet who threw a
challenge to the misogynist philosopher Nietzsche.
Kajal Ahmad |
Give me one night
I’ll make you look
like a fool.
Give me one night
The fortress of
your cockiness will get cracks.
Give me one night
I’ll transmute you
with a kiss
from
a thinker into a thought.
PS. I'm
participating in #BlogchatterA2Z of The Blogchatter
Tomorrow: Bhatti Mines is a symbol
Hari OM
ReplyDeleteWell, I am embarassed to say that this name change and slipped my notice! Having had contacts in Allahabad, you'd think I'd've noticed, but no... for even they still refer it such, even as Hindus. Then, I also know many who still refer Bombay. I could understand the renaming post-Raj... but this form you describe is like that which happened in Russia for St Petersburg/Petrograd/Leningrad (and back)... or Tsiritsyn/Stalingrad/Volgograd... One just holds the breath to think which place might become Modinagar! YAM xx
A=Arrival
Name changes take time for people to absorb. Bombay became Mumbai many years after the name was changed. So was Chennai. And many other places. People will slowly change. But attitudes have already changed!
DeleteInteresting incident at Khelgaon Public School. All the best to a2z campaign.
ReplyDeleteThank you. There are good and sensible people in UP too 😊
DeleteYogi has become the touchstone of power in India chanting Vasudeva Kudambakkam and abusing it.
ReplyDeleteYes. Not only Yogi, the entire right wing is hypocritical. They say what they don't mean and do just the opposite of what they preach.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletesorry for the typo . Its *CM
ReplyDeleteAs always, your post paints reality as is. I wish people like the founder of KPS get into politics and become CMs and continue the practice of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam. I know I'm a dreamer...
ReplyDeleteLet's keep dreaming. Some dreams do come true. But good people entering politics is a farfetched dream, I think.
DeleteThere are all sorts of people everywhere. I wouldn't generalize the people of a state or region. Yes, changing names takes away the place from the place. They once wanted to rename Shimla as Shyamla. I was heart broken. Thank god it didn't happen.
ReplyDeleteA state which reelects a man who has done all kinds of atrocities even to little children can be subjected to certain generalized verdicts. How else do we speak of that state?
Deletethe history of our country is so vivid and dynamic, and I believe that we should embrase it rather than try to change it. After all, the history has led us to what we are today (good and bad). Thus, instead of trying to change history and erase its memory by changing names etc, it would be much more fruitful to focus on bettering the future
ReplyDeleteWith you totally on this. Obsession with the past is dangerous. It will only damage the nation.
DeletePrayagraj, formerly known as Allahabad, is a vibrant city in India. It offers numerous captivating places to see in Prayagraj. The iconic Triveni Sangam, where three holy rivers converge, attracts pilgrims. The majestic Allahabad Fort, the historical Anand Bhavan, and the serene Khusro Bagh are also noteworthy attractions in Prayagraj.
ReplyDelete