I have read quite a few articles on the proposed Uniform Civil Code (UCC) and none of them seem to have anything good to say about it. Most of them view it as a political stunt meant to create a sectarian strife with the 2024 general elections around the corner. One of the best illustrations comes from Madhyamam weekly.
Uniform Civil Code is something that
the Constituent Assembly discussed in detail and left aside as something not
quite practical in a country like India which has too many diverse cultures and
practices. I lived in Shillong for a decade and a half. The people of Meghalaya
– Khasis, Garos and Jaintias – have their own traditional tribal cultures and practices
which are not like the mainland’s culture and practices at all. They all follow
slightly different versions of the matrilineal system. The youngest daughter
inherits the family property. The surname of the children comes from the mother
and not the father though the maternal uncle plays a vital role in many family
matters. The kind of UCC that Modi & Co envisage won’t work in Meghalaya
and many other tribal societies of India. In fact, it will destroy the entire
social fabric in those tribal states of the northeast.
Now, I can only assume that Modi’s
UCC won’t work in such places because Modi hasn’t given us any blueprint of the
proposed UCC. He has merely thrown the idea into the arena where some people
are expected to convert it into an effective electoral strategy.
Modi doesn’t have anything worthwhile
to show for seeking a third-time mandate. Too large a number of Indians have
relinquished Indian citizenship after 2014. The number of young people leaving
the country in search of dignified living is rising year after year. Modi’s Ram
Rajya is only a mirage, they know, except for a select few whose wealth keeps
piling up.
7.5 crore people were added to the Below Poverty Line population in 2021 alone. More are being added; the figures will come out slowly only. Modi’s “India has the world’s highest number of poor children, amounting to a total of 97 million or about 21.8 per cent of the Indian children population between the ages of 0 and 17 years.” [Down To Earth, 17 Oct 2022] This India is home to a sizeable chunk of the world’s poorest people.
From Down to Earth [link above] |
Nothing is really shining in Modi’s
India’s backyard, in short. Modi knows that. Hence he will need some electoral
ploy like the earlier Ayodhya Temple. Now it is UCC. When some kind of unity is
emerging among the opposition parties in the country and Modi feels threatened
electorally, UCC is hurled into the arena with the clear intention of creating
strife between Hindus and non-Hindus. Modi and Shah know very well that the
strife will help them garner the Hindu votes. And that’s all what they want.
While discussing the Hindu Civil
Code, Dr B R Ambedkar had said that whatever changes the upper caste Hindus may
make, the caste system that keeps certain sections of people including women enslaved
will continue to stay. Do you think the proposed UCC is going to liberate
Indians to a greater freedom? I’m interested in hearing from you. The comments
section below is open. Write away.
As pointed out in your post, it is only an election gimmick not likely to go any further.Best to ignore.
ReplyDeleteThat's the best solution for those who think. Unfortunately, the country is being run by people with brains that have gone to the netherworld.
DeleteAll these years we have been celebrating diversity, its only in the last decade that the idea of uniformity has been floated, obviously for political reasons and to wipe out any ideas that are contrarian. UCC is a NO NO.
ReplyDeleteThis One One slogan (One nation, one religion, etc) has something imperial about it. Old emperors felt secure when everything was to their own like and taste.
DeleteHari Om
ReplyDeleteOn this I can be but a mere observer; but also note that this is what Westminster thinks it can do with Scotland, Wales and NI, completely misunderstanding the very real cultural differences that exist... several of which have been successfully suppressed or even eradicated through the long years of it. And, to be fair, that some from each of those 'tribal' nations embraced their lords and masters after all... YAM xx
ps - back on the road today, so may be awol for a few! Yxx
DeleteToo many leaders who see themselves as great make this mistake of imposing their culture and language on entire peoples.
DeleteAll the best for the ongoing journey - adventure, should I say?
That illustration from Madhyamam says it all.
ReplyDelete