Skip to main content

We must be happy as a nation



In Plato’s Republic, Socrates compares the government to a shepherd. The government takes care of the citizens as a shepherd takes care of his sheep. Thrasymachus, another philosopher and a character in Plato’s book, rubbishes the analogy. The shepherd does take care of his sheep, says Thrasymachus. But for what? (1) To fleece them, and (2) to eat them. In the discourse that follows Thrasymachus argues that what passes for social justice is in fact a collection of laws and customs maintained by the ruling class for its own advantage.
Cynical as I am, I would not have given much credence to Thrasymachus until Mr Modi and his team started governing India. Many governments in India prior to Modi’s were also marked by corruption of all sorts. There is little that is surprising in that. Corruption is an integral part of politics. Even governments which were supposedly guided by divine revelations – like the Christian ones in the West or the Islamic ones in the Middle East – were marked by remarkably brutal levels of corruption. Even God could not safeguard governments from corruptibility.
Perhaps, God adds to the problem. The secular governments in India – or, for that matter, anywhere in the world – were far less vicious than the religious ones. Today India is governed by a political party whose principles emerge from a religion. And the results are more disastrous.

Millions of Indians are likely to end up in what BJP’s India calls “detention centres”. As many as ten such centres are already functional in the country and many more are being constructed. Are we moving in the direction of Hitler’s Germany? Possibly. The government calls this justice.
This is precisely what Thrasymachus meant. The justice practised by the BJP is safeguarding the interests of one group of people in the country. That group is the majority of citizens and they are happy. If they are happy the nation is happy. Because we are a democracy. The government can be certain to get the support of the majority because of this one reason alone. People are selfish and the government is exploiting that selfishness for its own political purposes. The government calls it justice. It sounds nice.
What happened in Delhi last week will prove beyond any doubt that it’s nothing about justice. The people who enjoy the government’s support looted the properties of the others and ejected them from their own homes. These people think that they can slowly appropriate everything belonging to the other people. New social justice!
But don’t forget that the government is not magnanimous to let you take it all. The government is the shepherd. Fleecing and killing will come to you in the due course of time. Just wait.
Plato’s Thrasymachus went much beyond this. I’m not going into all the details. But just one more point. Justice, as a moral principle, is purely an illusion.  Yes, the Greek philosopher says that in Plato’s Republic. It is an illusion invoked by the weak to protect themselves against the strong, whom otherwise they would be only too happy to imitate.
In other words, injustice, exploitation of others, grabbing their property, is what most of us will practise given a chance. The pre-Modi governments gave that chance to less people. Now more, a sizeably significant section of the citizens, have the chance. So we must be happy as a nation!


Comments

  1. Cynical but true. I hope Modi’s version of Hindu Nation will not happen because many Hindus have their versions and all want power. Vegetarianism will be opposed. Depriving certain classes of Hindus their rights will be difficult. Hindutva could not keep BJP-Shiv Sena together in Maharashtra.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think Modi and his lieutenant Shah will achieve the Hindu Rashtra by hook or by crook. See how dissent is suppressed and rebels are made to vanish. See how people of one particular religion are being eliminated systematically. See how non -BJP-ruled states are deprived of a lot of their rights.

      Delete
    2. Happen to read some of your blogs. extensive writing. Large wisdom.
      Nice.
      Paul, Global TV 98441 82044

      Delete
  2. Did you realize there's a 12 word phrase you can say to your partner... that will trigger intense emotions of love and impulsive appeal to you deep within his heart?

    Because deep inside these 12 words is a "secret signal" that triggers a man's instinct to love, idolize and care for you with his entire heart...

    12 Words That Trigger A Man's Love Instinct

    This instinct is so hardwired into a man's brain that it will drive him to try better than ever before to take care of you.

    As a matter of fact, fueling this all-powerful instinct is so important to having the best ever relationship with your man that once you send your man a "Secret Signal"...

    ...You will immediately notice him open his soul and mind to you in such a way he's never experienced before and he will distinguish you as the one and only woman in the universe who has ever truly tempted him.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Grandeur of the dooms

John Keats by William Hilton [Wikipedia] One of the poems included in CBSE’s class 12 English literature is an extract from Keats’ Endymion . A question that has come to me again and again from students as well as teachers is: What does “the grandeur of the dooms…” mean? It is a line that has perplexed me too. I have been amused by the kind of interpretations given in the guidebooks for students. Quite many of these books interpret the word ‘dooms’ to mean the Doomsday. Look at the following answer given in one such guidebook made available online by a well-known educational establishment.  That is very amusing considering the fact that Keats was an agnostic, if not a confirmed atheist. Keats would never accept a God who would come riding a majestic cloud on the day of the Last Judgment to apportion the good and the evil souls to Heaven and Hell. Evil is an integral part of life, Keats knew too well. No human can avoid evil any more than “a rose can avoid a blighting wind.” How...

Broligarchy

A page from Time Broligarchy is a new word I learnt from the latest issue of the Time magazine one of whose lead stories is titled ‘ American Broligarchy ’. Wikipedia teaches me that ‘broligarchy’ is “a neologism and portmanteau combining oligarchy and broism describing the rule of government by a coterie of extremely wealthy men (occupying leadership roles in the tech companies and tech-enabled businesses).” The Time article informs us that Trump’s greatest “bros” are Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and Mark Zuckerberg, the three men who were given the most prominent seats, ahead of Cabinet members, at Trump’s Presidential inauguration. These wealthy businessmen play crucial roles in Trump’s way of governing America. They pump a lot of unregulated money into politics for their own selfish reasons. A menacing outcome is an unhealthy (for the public) expansion of presidential power with fewer checks on the Congress. The Time laments that this “would be a recipe for more corruption under an...

The Adventures of Toto as a comic strip

  'The Adventures of Toto' is an amusing story by Ruskin Bond. It is prescribed as a lesson in CBSE's English course for class 9. Maggie asked her students to do a project on some of the lessons and Femi George's work is what I would like to present here. Femi converted the story into a beautiful comic strip. Her work will speak for itself and let me present it below.  Femi George Student of Carmel Public School, Vazhakulam, Kerala Similar post: The Little Girl

Anyone for a better world?

The above video was sent to me on WhatsApp by a friend who also asked me to write a blog post on the injustices of capitalism. The friend quoted Lenin: “Capitalism is going to give us the rope with which we are going to hang them.” I wasn’t particularly enthused by the message or the demand for a blog post because I am like Benjamin the donkey in Orwell’s Animal Farm . Benjamin is cynical when it comes to politics. He knows that no party or ideology is going to make any substantial difference as far as the common folk are concerned. What can be an alternative to capitalism, for instance? Socialism/Communism? Benign dictatorship? Theocracy? The video above shows the absolute heartlessness of capitalism. But has socialism/communism been any better in the erstwhile USSR, China, and present North Korea, Venezuela, and Cuba? Dictatorship and theocracy are not economic systems, but have they saved any nation from injustices? I believe the problem is not with systems or ideologies . T...

A Crazy Novel

Jayasree Kalathil, Sandhya Mary, and the book Book Review Title: Maria, Just Maria Author: Sandhya Mary Translator: Jayasree Kalathil T his is a crazy novel. It is hard to find a normal human being in it. There is more than one place in the narrative where we are told that every human being is insane to some degree. I won’t disagree with that. However, there are certain standards or wavelengths which are generally considered to be ‘normal’ if not sane and it is that normalcy which keeps the world going. Sandhya Mary’s debut novel flings a huge question mark on that normalcy. As I was reading this novel, I was constantly reminded of a joke that Albert Camus narrates in his brilliant essay on the meaning of life, The Myth of Sisyphus . A madman is sitting by a swimming pool with a fishing rod in hand. Seeing his serenity, his psychiatrist [I think in Camus’s own version it’s just a passerby – but I find the psychiatrist more appropriate] asks him whether he has caught any fish....