Media Watch
The Week
this time chooses to give us some “life lessons” from a few successful Indians
one of whom is Narayana Murthy. According to Murthy, a country like India where
poverty is a glaring problem, the government’s chief concern should be job
creation. But the government does not create jobs. It is only private entrepreneurs
who can do that. The government should provide “incentivising environment” to
the entrepreneurs.
India seems to
be more interested in entertaining the citizens with history’s blunders. The
Gyanvapi mosque dominated the country’s politics last week. Mosques and temples
are consuming India’s energy and time with no productive output whatever. When
prices of essential things are reaching the skies and life is becoming an
ordeal, it is easy to divert people’s attention using some red herring or a
wild goose chase. India now seems to be specialising in red herrings and wild geese. India Today
The India
Today’s Big Story this week is on Gyanvapi. The article mentions
the Places of Worship Act that was passed in 1991 by the Narasimha Rao
government when the Ayodhya issue was taken to a feverish pitch by L K Advani.
According to that Act, the religious character of all places of worship –
except Ayodhya which was under litigation – shall be retained as it was on 15
Aug 1947.
Even when the
Supreme Court allowed the construction of the Ram temple in Ayodhya in Nov
2019, the apex court upheld the provisions in the 1991 Act saying, “In
preserving the character of places of public worship, Parliament has mandated
in no uncertain terms that history
and its wrongs shall not be used as instruments to oppress the present and the
future.”
India has,
nevertheless, chosen to bury its head like the metaphorical ostrich in the
sands of the dead past. The India Today’s Big Story
concludes with an observation from the Congress leader, Gaurav Kapoor: “Varanasi
is very much a land of entrepreneurs and we like to focus on that rather than
anything else like ‘What did Aurangzeb do?’ and ‘What did Babur do?’ This is
just hundred percent political propaganda. Wouldn’t it be nice if we stopped to worry about the economy
for once?” Gaurav Kapoor echoed Narayana Murthy. There are hundreds of thousands
of Indians who will echo similar thoughts. But they are all rendered powerless
by ostriches with heads in sands. Open
The Open
magazine is all praise for India, however. It is praise for Modi, rather. This
week’s issue chooses to celebrate Modi’s eight “successful” years. The preface
to the magazine’s panegyric begins thus: “Eight years after Narendra Modi took
office as prime minister, the fact that India has been fundamentally
transformed is not open to debate.” The Open is so sure about India’s
progress under Modi that it won’t even let us a debate. It just gives us a
series of stories to convince us that we are living in a quasi-paradise, thanks
to Modi’s profound vision and policies.
According to
P R Ramesh of the Open, Modi put an end in 2014 to “corruption, inefficiency,
political appeasement, … terrorism, crony capitalism (ah, that’s a nice one
indeed) and blackmail by regional leaders.” The greatest contribution of Modi
to India is the boost he gave to the country’s national(ist) morale by returning
its deserved respectability to Hinduism. “As the first prime minister,” writes
Ramesh, “who unabashedly wore tilak and tika on his forehead, sported saffron
and recited shlokas and openly embraced his own moorings by visiting temples
from Kashi to Kedarnath to Somnath, Modi renewed a fundamental connection with
ordinary people in a way that was not only dignified and triggered a resurgence
of hope but seemed utterly neutral.”
As you read Ramesh’s
long-winded article, you may wonder whether Modi is India’s prime minister or
its High Priest (a Pope of sorts). But Ramesh is not the only Modi-fan at the Open.
Probably, the Open’s official policy is to keep Modi ji pleased and stay
clear of raids from the Enforcement Directorate or the CBI or the Income Tax mandarins.
At any rate, the youngsters who are preparing for Public Service Commission’s tests
and interviews would do well to read this issue of the Open. They can
get enough and more points to glorify their country and particularly its
present government.
Speaking
about youngsters, let me conclude this week’s Media Watch with a piece of advice that Ramachandra
Guha gives to youngsters who aspire to be writers. This is from the Week
again. Don’t write to become famous, says Guha. Write about something that is a
literary or intellectual challenge. Write with determination and integrity with
no regard for success. “Success is incidental. It is really the quality of work
that must give you satisfaction.”
PS. Previous Media Watch: The
Other Side of Sedition
This new thing is horrifying, we need to learn from history and course correct
ReplyDeleteInstead we are repeating history's blunders.
DeleteYes, sir. I agree with the quoted lines of Ramachandra Guha. Well said!
ReplyDelete*Open* is closed ti such writing with integrity, I can see.
Integrity is at a premium now in India.
DeleteHari OM
ReplyDeleteIntegrity, I fear, is at great premium everywhere! I am much appreciating these roundups, Tomichan. YAM xx
Thanks for the appreciation. 🙏
DeleteIntegrity is almost a vice nowadays!
May b they shud hav covered fixing national award to kanganna as one of achievements of Modi govt....i saw a msg where a circular was released in school stating to vote for mandir in place of that gyanvapi mosque asking for support. It may b foul play by some grps but it's saddening as it's a school
ReplyDeletePeople suffering from severe myopia are our rulers. And they have ulterior motives. Hence the situation will worsen.
DeleteGyanvapi case should not have been allowed. Places of Worship Act 1991 is ignored. All over India we see demands for demolition of mosques.
ReplyDeleteGyanvapi is just the beginning. We are going to witness a lot of demolitions and they won't end with mosques.
Delete