Skip to main content

The other side of sedition

Media Watch


The sedition law got much media attention in the past week, thanks to the Supreme Court’s freezing of the colonial law. Not one newspaper or magazine that I read supports the sedition law. Every one of them welcomes and appreciates the SC’s interim order.

Writing in the Hindustan Times of 13 May, former judge of the SC, Deepak Gupta, asserts in no uncertain terms that the “sedition law has no place in a democracy.” Who wants to retain such an antiquated law? Those who are afraid of criticism do. Stifling criticism is to create a police state, argues Gupta. Certain restrictions are required when it comes to freedom of expression. No nation can afford to compromise its security, foreign relationships, public order, decency and morality. But putting charges of sedition on people who criticise the government’s policies is to invite troubles.

Gupta quotes Mahatma Gandhi who was arrested for sedition by the British. “Affection (for the government or country) cannot be manufactured or regulated by law,” said Gandhi. “If one has no affection for a person or system, one should be free to give the fullest expression to his disaffection, so long as he does not contemplate, promote or incite to violence.” The disaffection that Gandhi was referring to was the one mentioned in Section 124A of the Indian Penal Code which criminalises “exciting disaffection against the government”. Gupta implicitly suggests that no government with self-confidence requires the sedition law.

The Times of India’s editorial on 12 May bluntly asks the government to scrap the sedition law. “Don’t just reform – remove,” screamed the title of the editorial. Even a mild version of the law will be misused, the editor thinks. This law in any shape will provide the opportunity for politicians to settle scores with rivals or critics. The newspaper goes on to say that even UAPA needs be scrapped.

The Free Press Journal’s editorial of 13 May mentions that about 13,000 people are in prisons now charged with sedition. The number alone hints at the blatant misuse of the law. Many of these prisoner won’t be convicted since their crimes won’t amount to anything like sedition. But the mere detention is punishment.

The Morning Standard also mentions the number 13,000 and adds that 60% of them were implicated after the BJP came to power at the centre. The newspaper’s editorial (12 May) states explicitly that the ruling party is abusing the law.

D Raja of the CPI wrote an article in the Indian Express of 13 May arguing vociferously against the sedition law and added that cases under the UAPA have increased by about 75% between 2017 and 2020. The BJP is obviously too scared of criticism. The party does need a stronger backbone.

*

The Open magazine has Siddharth Singh writing a long article about the freebies being given to people by governments for the sake of (cheap) popularity. Interestingly, the writer cites examples only from Punjab and Rajasthan, two non-BJP states. One wonders why he fails to see more freebies being given by the Modi government as well as the BJP state governments.

His question is valid, however. Should governments indulge in such populist measures which are rather costly by any criterion? Shouldn’t governments focus on policies and acts that bring in welfare for all instead of select groups? Shouldn’t governments have clearer vision about brighter future for all people instead of giving alms to the people?

*

The Week this time has dedicated half of its pages to the preeminent Bengali film maker, Satyajit Ray. His classical movie Pather Panchali has survived 7 decades. The Week argues that the contemporary Bengali cinema is too substandard in comparison with Ray’s movies. There is a parallel decline in Bengali literature too. It is quite amazing that a people that had artists and writers who scaled enviable peaks of excellence are now fumbling in the dark alleys of mediocrity. What has happened to Bengal? The Week wonders.


*

That question about Bengal can be extended to the whole of India now, I think. That is quite tragic. Why are we obsessed with the past? Why are we interested in the dark chambers of the Taj Mahal instead of the bright possibilities that should be explored for the sake of the emerging young population of the country? Why are we stuck in the quagmire of history instead of dealing with the present and its innumerable problems?

PS. Last Media Watch:  Exotic India

Comments

  1. Yamini MacLeanMay 15, 2022 at 4:14 PM

    Hari OM
    Top notch round up again, my friend! Interesting that there is starting to be a revolt against the sedition law - do the voices for this run risk themselves? Here in the UK, the government is seeking to finalise a bill that will give the police greater powers to detain anyone protesting, such as environmental activists, women's rights, race rights, workers rights... in other words, criticism of the ruling party by raising a banner is likely to land one in gaol. Backward indeed... YAM xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tomichan MatheikalMay 15, 2022 at 5:34 PM

      It's a good sign that the Indian media gathered the courage to speak this much. Let's hope things will change for the better.

      Delete
  2. magiceyeMay 15, 2022 at 7:03 PM

    Our 'leaders' wish to dwell in the past as they have no vision for the future and they wish to keep the populace numb in the past.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tomichan MatheikalMay 15, 2022 at 7:39 PM

      Exactly. Lack of vision keeps us rooted in the past.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Little Girl

The Little Girl is a short story by Katherine Mansfield given in the class 9 English course of NCERT. Maggie gave an assignment to her students based on the story and one of her students, Athena Baby Sabu, presented a brilliant job. She converted the story into a delightful comic strip. Mansfield tells the story of Kezia who is the eponymous little girl. Kezia is scared of her father who wields a lot of control on the entire family. She is punished severely for an unwitting mistake which makes her even more scared of her father. Her grandmother is fond of her and is her emotional succour. The grandmother is away from home one day with Kezia's mother who is hospitalised. Kezia gets her usual nightmare and is terrified. There is no one at home to console her except her father from whom she does not expect any consolation. But the father rises to the occasion and lets the little girl sleep beside him that night. She rests her head on her father's chest and can feel his heart...
16 comments
Read more

The Call of Islamic State

A year ago, the International Centre for Counter-Terrorism – The Hague (ICCT) reported that about 4000 people from the West left their homes and countries to join the Islamic State (IS).  Many of them are women.  The reporters had made a special study of the women who joined the terrorist outfit and found that it was difficult to categorise which type of women were particularly drawn to IS. “While most of the girls are young, some as young as fifteen,” says the report,  “there are also mothers with young children who make the trip. Some of the girls have difficulties in school and are said to have an IQ below average,  but there are also women who are highly educated. It also appears that even though a relatively large portion of the girls had (or still have) a troubled childhood, there are some who come from families with no known problems with the authorities. Most of the girls come from religiously moderate Muslim families,  yet some converted to Islam a...
33 comments
Read more

The Plague

When the world today is struggling with the pandemic of Covid-19, Albert Camus’s novel The Plague can offer some stimulating lessons. When a plague breaks out in the city of Oran, initially the political authorities fail to deal with it as a serious problem. The ordinary people also don’t view it as an epidemic that requires public action rather than as individual annoyances. The people of Oran are obsessed with their personal sufferings and inconveniences. Finally the authorities are forced to put Oran in quarantine. Father Paneloux, a Jesuit priest, delivers a sermon declaring the epidemic as God’s punishment for Oran’s sins. Months of suffering make people rise above their selfish notions and obsessions and join anti-plague efforts being carried out by people like Dr Rieux. Dr Rieux is an atheist but committed to service of humanity. He questions Father Paneloux’s religious views when a small boy is killed by the epidemic. The priest delivers another sermon on the necess...
28 comments
Read more

AAP and I

Who defeated Arvind Kejriwal?  Himself or us? His party ruled for just 49 days.  They were momentous days.  He implemented his promise on setting up a number for reporting corruption; in two weeks instead of the promised two days.  He met people to discuss corruption issues, though the crowd was beyond his control.  He did what he could.  He would have done more if he could.  He put an end to the VVIP culture in politics.  The politician became aam aadmi.  Ministers started travelling in vehicles without the screaming red lights and horrifying screeches.  But the police had to go out of their way to provide protection to the chief minister.  Who defeated the chief minister’s vision that political leaders need no such protection from their own people? He revolutionised the admission procedures in schools.  Schools which charged hefty amounts from parents illegally stood to lose.  The aam aadmi would have g...
25 comments
Read more

Farewell to a Friend

This is a season of farewells for me.  I have lost count of the persons who have already left or are being hauled up before the firing line by the Orwellian Big Brother in the last quarter of the year.  The person, to whom we bid farewell today, however, had chosen to leave on his own.  He is going as the Principal of R K International School , Sarkaghat, Himachal Pradesh. Mr S K Sharma was a colleague and friend.  He belongs to the species of human beings whose company enriches you and whose departure creates a vacuum, notwithstanding the fact that Nature which abhors vacuum will fill it in its own unique ways.  Administration is an art for Mr Sharma, though he calls it a skill.  Management lessons, strategies and heuristics are only guidelines.  No one can manage people merely with the help of these guidelines.  People are not machines which can be controlled mechanically.  Machines work according to rules.  People do not d...
31 comments
Read more