Book Review
I read this book purely by chance. R K Narayan is not
a writer whom I would choose for any reason whatever. He is too simple,
simplistic. I was at school on Saturday last and I suddenly found myself
without anything to do though I was on duty. Some duties are like that: like a
traffic policeman’s duty on a road without any traffic! So I went up to the school
library and picked up a book which looked clean. It happened to be Waiting
for the Mahatma by R K Narayan. A small book of 200 pages which I
almost finished reading on the same day.
The novel was originally published in
1955, written probably as a tribute to Mahatma Gandhi and India’s struggle for
independence. The edition that I read is a later reprint by Penguin Classics.
Twenty-year-old Sriram is the
protagonist though Gandhi towers above everybody else in the novel just as he
did in India of the independence-struggle years. Sriram who lives with his
grandmother inherits significant wealth when he turns 20. His parents were dead
long ago. Sriram was a mediocre student at school and did nothing to improve
himself later either. But a chance encounter with Bharati, a young and beautiful
disciple of Mahatma Gandhi, transforms him totally. He decides to become a
Gandhian. Bharati guides him exquisitely.
In a way, this is a coming-of-age
novel. The frivolous young man grows up into a mature patriot and nationalist.
Gandhi appears again and again with much inspiration. R K Narayan’s Gandhi is saintlier
than the real Gandhi. Gandhi in this novel looks like an abstract ideal without
any human frailty. And Bharati is a perfect disciple. Sriram is all too human,
mercifully.
Sriram’s story is a skilful interplay
between individual desires and nationalistic fervour. What really propels
Sriram towards nationalism is his ardour for Bharati. There is no other way for
securing Bharati’s affection than by becoming a Gandhian nationalist. Narayan
is successful in dealing with Sriram’s growth into maturity and psychological
depth.
Sriram has to struggle with his
affection for his grandmother too. Grandmother doesn’t appreciate his
nationalism. She doesn’t have any regard for people like Gandhi who are nothing
more than trouble-makers. Why can’t Sriram live comfortably with the wealth she
has amassed for him in the bank? Why does he opt for the discomforts of a
Gandhian ashram when there is luxury waiting for him at home?
Grandmother is nearly heart-broken
with Sriram’s prolonged absence from home. Towards the end of the novel, she is
assumed to be dead and is taken to the cremation ground. Sriram reaches in time
for the cremation after his release from jail. However, as the pyre caches
fire, it is discovered that grandmother is alive. She is saved. But the same villagers
who were grief-stricken hitherto are now absolutely opposed to the idea of the
old woman’s return to the village. No one returns to the village from the
grave. If they do, it will be ominous for the village. Grandmother abandons her
home and chooses the holy premises of Banaras for the remaining days of her
life. Narayan is best while dealing with characters like this grandmother.
The novel moves on to a great denouement
which is a national calamity: the assassination of the Mahatma for whose
arrival Sriram was waiting along with Bharati.
This simple story is a charming look
at the freedom struggle years of India and Gandhi’s role in that struggle.
Narayan is able to weave the communal clashes of the Partition days seamlessly
into the narrative. A unique simplicity underlies the entire narrative in spite
of all the conflict and tension. While that simplicity has its own mellow sweetness,
it fails to see the complex depths of human existence and struggles.
I think I will go with you. It's difficult to feel a oneness with such narratives.
ReplyDeleteProbably when it was written it evoked entirely different feelings in the reader.
DeleteHari Om
ReplyDelete... but perhaps another book to point your students toward? YAM xx
That's just right. Though I wonder how many students actually read good literature now.
DeleteIt sounds like a book of its time. Not great, but sometimes we can learn a lot from not great books.
ReplyDeleteA good book of its time, that's it. Narayan was a well-approved writer of his time.
DeleteGreat to read about Waiting for the Mahatma, well written.
ReplyDeleteI too find RK Narayan's books simplistic. I read Waiting for the Mahatma for a book club and couldn't appreciate it because I couldn't like the protagonist. It didn't even work as a coming-of-age novel because Sriram doesn't really come of age. He seems to drift along with whatever ideology catches his fancy at the moment. In fact Bharati was the real hero of this book.
ReplyDeleteYes, the novel leaves us without quite satisfying us. I think 'Guide' is the best work of Narayan. Malgudi days have their own childish delights, no doubt.
Delete