Skip to main content

Whose India?


“If you keep doing the same things, you will keep getting the same results,” Dave Ramsey said. It doesn’t matter who Dave Ramsey is. I don’t know, in fact. Albert Einstein could have said that as well.

From the time BJP came to power in Delhi, India has been doing more or less the same thing: sectarian politics which favours one particular community and marginalises all others. Since the majority of Indians belong to the community favoured by BJP, no other party could arrive at an effective strategy for winning elections. People obviously want favours from those in power. And BJP is giving those favours to the majority. The majority will then vote BJP. BJP continues to rule. Happily. Till date.

And so some genius in the other camp struck upon a strategy. Divide the majority community along caste lines. This is not a new strategy at all. This was effectively made use of in all the Hindi belt states earlier many times by many parties. What is new now is that almost all the non-BJP parties have come together under one umbrella named INDIA [Indian National Developmental Inclusive Alliance]. That was quite a masterstroke. So much so, Mr Modi decided to change the name of the country to Bharat! Did the opposition’s INDIA create a few cracks in Modi’s India? Modi wobbled, no doubt.

The Alliance called INDIA wanted caste-based census which made Modi’s wobble much more unsteady. Modi’s party is the party of the upper castes.

Just a few statistics.

Most of the top jobs/positions in India are held by upper caste Hindus. Out of the 89 central government secretaries [highest officers in the government machinery], there is only one SC [Scheduled Caste]. There are 3 STs [Scheduled Tribe]. There’s not even a single OBC [Other Backward Community].

Out of the 93 additional secretaries, 6 are SCs, 5 STs and no OBC.

Look at the top positions in the judiciary or the police force or the army or anywhere and you will find similar statistics.

Is there any OBC at the top of the RSS? [Read Bhanwar Meghwanshi’s book I Could Not Be Hindu to know more about the caste biases of RSS.]

Let me insert a very telling parable here. Last month Adani’s Vizhinjam Port in Kerala was inaugurated by the Prime Minister. Two days prior to the inauguration, the Managing Director Adeela Abdulla, who was doing a commendable job in the post, was replaced by Dr Divya S Iyer. Both are IAS officers. The former was doing such a great job that there was no reason for her replacement. But the replacement did take place. Why? Look at the names.

Only 12% of India’s population are upper castes. This small fraction of the country’s population has appropriated 80% of all the top offices in the country. A mere 4% of such jobs are held by the lower castes who constitute 52% of the population.

Let me bring in a contrast. Out of the 4 Chief Ministers of Congress, 3 are OBCs. Of the ten BJP CMs, only one is an OBC.

When the INDIA alliance was formed, Modi’s typical answer was the declaration of the Vishwakarma Yojana, which was meant for splitting the lower caste into two factions: those who benefit from the Yojana and those who don’t. Divide and Rule is not just a British strategy.

Of course, there are better strategies coming up. The Ayodhya Temple, for instance. It will be inaugurated in Jan 2024, just weeks before the Lok Sabha elections. It will take certain core sentiments to orgasmic levels which in turn will reap rich dividends in the elections.

Modi’s India keeps doing the same things. From 2014. And it keeps getting the same results.

Who benefits? You tell me.

PS. This post is provoked by Indispire Edition 459: "If the problems you have this year are the same problems you had last year, then you are not a leader. You are rather a problem on your own that must be solved." Israelmore Ayivor #ProblemLeader

Comments

  1. Ah yes, those in power want to keep power. And they'll use whatever tools they can to do so.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tragically it all ends as mere power games. All the talk about ideologies like cultural nationalism becomes sheer hogwash. In the process a lot of innocent people become unnecessary victims.

      Delete
  2. Replies
    1. They have no imagination whatever for conjuring up something new.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Grandeur of the dooms

John Keats by William Hilton [Wikipedia] One of the poems included in CBSE’s class 12 English literature is an extract from Keats’ Endymion . A question that has come to me again and again from students as well as teachers is: What does “the grandeur of the dooms…” mean? It is a line that has perplexed me too. I have been amused by the kind of interpretations given in the guidebooks for students. Quite many of these books interpret the word ‘dooms’ to mean the Doomsday. Look at the following answer given in one such guidebook made available online by a well-known educational establishment.  That is very amusing considering the fact that Keats was an agnostic, if not a confirmed atheist. Keats would never accept a God who would come riding a majestic cloud on the day of the Last Judgment to apportion the good and the evil souls to Heaven and Hell. Evil is an integral part of life, Keats knew too well. No human can avoid evil any more than “a rose can avoid a blighting wind.” How...

Broligarchy

A page from Time Broligarchy is a new word I learnt from the latest issue of the Time magazine one of whose lead stories is titled ‘ American Broligarchy ’. Wikipedia teaches me that ‘broligarchy’ is “a neologism and portmanteau combining oligarchy and broism describing the rule of government by a coterie of extremely wealthy men (occupying leadership roles in the tech companies and tech-enabled businesses).” The Time article informs us that Trump’s greatest “bros” are Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and Mark Zuckerberg, the three men who were given the most prominent seats, ahead of Cabinet members, at Trump’s Presidential inauguration. These wealthy businessmen play crucial roles in Trump’s way of governing America. They pump a lot of unregulated money into politics for their own selfish reasons. A menacing outcome is an unhealthy (for the public) expansion of presidential power with fewer checks on the Congress. The Time laments that this “would be a recipe for more corruption under an...

The Adventures of Toto as a comic strip

  'The Adventures of Toto' is an amusing story by Ruskin Bond. It is prescribed as a lesson in CBSE's English course for class 9. Maggie asked her students to do a project on some of the lessons and Femi George's work is what I would like to present here. Femi converted the story into a beautiful comic strip. Her work will speak for itself and let me present it below.  Femi George Student of Carmel Public School, Vazhakulam, Kerala Similar post: The Little Girl

A Crazy Novel

Jayasree Kalathil, Sandhya Mary, and the book Book Review Title: Maria, Just Maria Author: Sandhya Mary Translator: Jayasree Kalathil T his is a crazy novel. It is hard to find a normal human being in it. There is more than one place in the narrative where we are told that every human being is insane to some degree. I won’t disagree with that. However, there are certain standards or wavelengths which are generally considered to be ‘normal’ if not sane and it is that normalcy which keeps the world going. Sandhya Mary’s debut novel flings a huge question mark on that normalcy. As I was reading this novel, I was constantly reminded of a joke that Albert Camus narrates in his brilliant essay on the meaning of life, The Myth of Sisyphus . A madman is sitting by a swimming pool with a fishing rod in hand. Seeing his serenity, his psychiatrist [I think in Camus’s own version it’s just a passerby – but I find the psychiatrist more appropriate] asks him whether he has caught any fish....

Anyone for a better world?

The above video was sent to me on WhatsApp by a friend who also asked me to write a blog post on the injustices of capitalism. The friend quoted Lenin: “Capitalism is going to give us the rope with which we are going to hang them.” I wasn’t particularly enthused by the message or the demand for a blog post because I am like Benjamin the donkey in Orwell’s Animal Farm . Benjamin is cynical when it comes to politics. He knows that no party or ideology is going to make any substantial difference as far as the common folk are concerned. What can be an alternative to capitalism, for instance? Socialism/Communism? Benign dictatorship? Theocracy? The video above shows the absolute heartlessness of capitalism. But has socialism/communism been any better in the erstwhile USSR, China, and present North Korea, Venezuela, and Cuba? Dictatorship and theocracy are not economic systems, but have they saved any nation from injustices? I believe the problem is not with systems or ideologies . T...