My copy of Great Expectations |
Charles Dickens does not appear in the list of my favourite
novelists, notwithstanding the fact that he is an admirable story-teller. He
weaves fantastic plots with too much happening at any time. There are all sorts
of characters in his works. There is no dearth of melodrama and sentiments, and
even the grotesque. In spite of all that, Dickens remains at a considerable
distance from my affections. I think the problem is that his characters become
conventional mouthpieces of conventional sentiments when confronted with crises.
Pip, the protagonist of Great
Expectations, has remained with me for a long time. He has made some
sort of an indelible impression on my fancy. His real name is Philip Pirrip but
is known as Pip throughout the novel. Right in the first pages of the novel, we
meet Pip as a little boy in the local cemetery where his parents are buried. As
he is wandering about there, he is caught by “a fearful man, all in coarse
grey, with a great iron on his leg.” The man threatens to slit the boy’s throat
if he makes any noise. Pip pleads, “O! Don’t cut my throat, sir.” The man grabs
Pip by his ankles and turns him upside down to see if there are some coins in
his pockets. There isn’t any; there is just a piece of bread. Pip is too poor
to have any money on him.
That scene of Abel Magwitch, escaped
convict, holding Pip by his ankles with the church yonder looking upside down
to him, is one of the most unforgettable scenes of the novel for me. Magwitch
will eventually turn Pip’s real world upside down. He will whet the boy’s
longings for a far better life, his “great expectations.”
Pip wants to be a wealthy gentleman
though he is an extremely poor orphan being taken care of by his sister whose
husband is a simple (simpleton) blacksmith Joe. However, Pip inherits a fortune
from an anonymous benefactor who later, much later, turns out to be the convict
Magwitch who made it big with some luck and a lot of honest hard work. When Pip
comes to know who his benefactor really is, he is shocked. His ego is hurt. His
ideals rise in revolt. His moral sensibility is shaken.
As Pip rose to certain heights in
society with his education and the support of the mysterious benefactor, Pip
had become arrogant and snobbish. He didn’t like people like Joe anymore.
However, his awareness about his
benefactor brings him down from all those social mores and slants to the raw
reality. There is disillusionment and subsequent suffering. Such
disillusionment and suffering can shatter a person. But in Pip’s case, it
becomes a redemptive force. Pip undergoes a profound transformation. He
acquires humility, sense of gratitude and loyalty to people like Joe who love
him genuinely. He realises that affection and relationships are far more
important than social advancement, wealth and class.
The novel ends in a typical
Dickensian melodrama. Nevertheless, it is an eminent entertainer. After all,
who entertained the Victorian England better than Dickens?
PS. This post is a part of Blogchatter Half Marathon
Hari Om
ReplyDeleteI read a gread deal of Dickens in my youth. Haven't touched it since. I barely remembered the tale of Pip as you retold it here. So not much impression left on me! YAM xx
I can understand. Dickens won't appeal to someone like you.
DeleteI too haven't read Dickens except for A Christmas Carol. I like how crisply and simply you have narrated the tale.
ReplyDeleteMy summary is nothing more than a skeleton. I'm focusing on one aspect, that's all.
DeleteHad read this long back and don't remember much of it.
ReplyDeletePop fiction doesn't make lasting impressions.
DeleteI read this in junior high. I liked it at the time. I wonder how it would hit me now. I tried to read other Dickens novels after that, but I just couldn't get through them.
ReplyDeleteYoung readers still like Dickens. As we grow older, we become aware of the plot machinations.
DeleteGreat Expectations was part of our syllabus in high school as well as college. So I went through this novel twice. I did not have fancy for Pip but I loved the character of Joe Gargery who embodied universal and timeless values like untarnished love for Pip who mistreats him having risen the social ladder. Ms. Havisham's time warp had a profound impact on me. I guess it's Esther's aloofness which egged Pip more towards social advancement. His disenchantment towards his real benefactor is annoying. It rips Pip off his fake realities and shatters his make believe world.
ReplyDeleteGreat review encapsulating the narrative in engaging brevity.
What makes Pip interesting to me is precisely his imperfection. Joe is most lovable but too good and simple to be an interesting character. Miss Havisham would have been a mere caricature in the hands of a lesser writer.
DeleteYes, Joe is static while Pip evolves.
ReplyDelete