Has Christmas been hijacked by Santa Claus and his
snow cap? And also by plastic? This is a concern raised by a friend who is also
a Catholic priest. Watching the Christmas celebrations around me in the last
few days in various places – religious as well as secular – I know my friend’s
concern is genuine.
Christmas has been “Caesarianized,”
he says. The spiritual preparation during the Advent season has given way to
Santa Claus and his jingle bells. To discount sales in shopping malls. What’s
worse, various Christian organisations send out carol teams on floridly
decorated open vehicles equipped with high decibel loudspeakers that shatter all
the peace while blaring out carols on ‘Peace to people with goodwill.’
It is a Christmas without Jesus.
Santa Clauses tower far above the diminutive figure of infant Jesus, if the
latter is there at all in the carol teams and other celebrations. Look at any
commercial brought out during the season and you will think that Christmas is
all about Santa Claus and his red and white colours. And merrymaking. Light and
sound. Sound and fury.
It is Christmas without the Christ!
Without love, hope, and redemption.
Just below my friend’s WhatsApp message
of concern was the link to a hate speech by a Hindu ascetic. I mean, the man looked
like an ascetic in his saffron robes which resembled Yogi Adityanath’s costume.
I wanted to bring the link here, though the speech was in Malayalam, because it
was an ideal example of the kind of toxicity that religion has become in India
today. But the video has been removed from YouTube. Probably a lot of
complaints were made by sensible people.
The speech followed the attack on the
Christmas celebrations in a school in Kerala by the Vishwa Hindu Parishad. The
speaker argues that India being a Hindu Rashtra, it doesn’t require Christmas
and carols. There should only be Krishna Jayanti and Hindu festivals. Of
course, people who make such arguments may be a minority population of the
country, but such fringe elements are gathering more and more followers. Though
I wrote recently in a WhatsApp group of some old classmates that the turn of
Christians to be oppressed would come as soon as they (you know who they
are) finish with the Muslims, I hadn’t thought it would start in Kerala so
quickly.
Kerala has a good secular culture.
The people of the state are open to any kind of diversity. They are the people
who democratically elected a communist party government, first such in the
world, in 1957. Their ancestors were the people who embraced Christianity and
later Islam because of many valid reasons. Today, a sizeable chunk of the state’s
population lives happily in other countries because of their readiness to
accept new realities, cultures, traditions, etc with an open mind, though the
openness may have more to do with ruthless pragmatism than intellectual depth.
My personal hope with ample reasons
was that Kerala would remain untouched for a long while yet by the kind of hate
being spewed in the name of the majority religion in other states. But now I
can see too many people of the majority religion going out of their way to
justify the oppressions of the minorities. [Nearly half of Kerala’s population
are Muslims and Christians.]
So, should the minorities start shouting
louder? As they seem to be doing now with the increasing decibels of Christmas
carols and the preponderance of Santa Clauses.
No, I have argued in many places that
the answer to religious oppression is not more religion but more sanity. I am
not naïve to say that the Christians of India should let themselves be
persecuted abiding by the ideals of the Sermon
on the Mount literally. The Sermon on the Mount is good poetry and better
theology. But it won’t work today except in the walled communities of
monasteries.
Religious oppression, especially state-sanctioned
varieties, need to be dealt with diplomatically. Engaging with the legal
systems of the country is one way. The judiciary has also been saffronised in
India and it is difficult to get justice from it. Difficulties can be faced with
resilience if you are on a spiritual journey. Use the power of education (as
Kerala has been doing eminently), build coalitions, empower the community using
whatever resources at hand, develop economic self-reliance, organise nonviolent
and meaningful resistance movements, use symbols, art, cultural expressions,
etc, engage with the government in dialogue and negotiation… Well, I guess
there are ways and ways of solving problems other than doing what your
oppressor is doing.
When Santa Claus overrides the infant
Jesus, it is very spirit of Christmas that gets trampled over. Perhaps, it is
high time for the churches in Kerala (and elsewhere as well) to take a deep
look within.
Yes. " Deep Look within. "Sanity calls for Silence and Critical Introspection in Depth.... And abut the otherwise tolerant monk, this time over, he turned rabid, to make the point out that Christian Revivalism would not carryl far and perhaps need to be checked, as it smacks of Vasco Da Gama colonial Domination. And Revivalism of any hue, Christian, Muslim and Hindu is sarcastic Domination. Thanks for the well-written piece, which reached me as an after-Christmas Mornig Gift. And returning to the Monk, he has been a vehement and sarcastic and caustic critic of Sangh Parivar and the machinations of Suresh Gopi, the actor in reel and real life as a continuum, when he was trying to take over Thrissivaperur.
ReplyDeleteI had no idea about this monk until you sent me the link. The obscenity of his indignation doesn't make me think he can be tolerant except as expediency. I can understand the kind of arrogant fear that seems to be driving his passion, the fear of Christian domineerance which has an intellectual edge over Muslim approaches.
DeleteSuresh has no depth whatever. He's not fit to be anything other than the bombastic roles he played in movies. The way he manipulated the church in Trichur manifested his absolute lack principles and personal morality. The church also revealed a similar deviousness converting Gopi's election to a mutual benefit scheme.
Not Sarcastic, but subtle and gross domination, symbolic or otherwise.
ReplyDeleteLife (religion, music. politics etc) has been hijacked by commercial interests hence no purity, only dilution.
ReplyDeleteContamination rather than dilution is what I'd say.
DeleteWell written...
ReplyDeleteMerry Christmas!
Hari OM
ReplyDeleteAs ever, you hit the mark with your writing, Tomichan. The rise of commercialism for Christmas (and Easter) has long been a matter of debate in the western churches. That there is the added complication of Hindutva seeking to sour its own core principles with hatred and venom is surely a pain upon the soul. YAM xx
My present-day dream is to see a world where religion becomes really what it is supposed to be.
DeleteThe majority religion will always oppress. It's what organized religions do. Sadly. When it comes to Christmas, I keep in mind that the church really has no idea when Jesus was born. They only took December 25th because they were trying to usurp a Pagan celebration. (Saturnalia? Something like that.) They *know* when Easter is (hence why it adheres to a lunar calendar and moves every year). But Jesus' birth? Nah.
ReplyDeleteAnd, look at complaints about Christmas in prior centuries, and you will find similar complaints. Too commercial. Have forgotten the purpose. Etc.
The date probably is insignificant. We know birthdays didn't matter back then. But the message, how that's being drowned by all the noise and glitter.
DeleteThe God's own country always stood out from rest of the nation! Hopefully It will also survive the political repression!!
ReplyDeleteBtw, new to your blog sir and I loved the way you have put things.
Glad you visited and look forward to more visits.
Delete