Book Review
Author:
David Michie
Publisher:
Hay House India, 2013
Pages:
216 Price: Rs 399
This
is a good book for those who want to have a quick and fairly meaningful peep
into Tibetan Buddhism and its current headquarters in Dharamsala and
around. If you are, however, fairly
familiar with Buddhism as well as motivational books, this book may disappoint
you.
In
most places the approach of the book is quite simplistic. Simplicity is an adorable quality; but being
simplistic is not. Look at the Dalai
Lama’s advice on anger, for example:
“It
(anger) is not permanent. It is not part
of you. You cannot say, ‘I’ve always
been an angry person.’ Your anger
arises, abides, and passes, just like anyone else’s. You may experience it more than others. And each time you give in to it, you feed the
habit and make it more likely you will feel it again. Wouldn’t it be better, instead, to decrease
its power?” [p.130]
[If you find that advice profound,
please skip the rest of this review.]
The
book is full of such advice and thoughts.
There are a few places where the level of the preaching rises to
subtlety and even becomes sublime. For
example, “One of the last things Buddha said to his followers was that anyone
who believed a word he had taught them was a fool – unless they had tested it
against their own experience,” says a monk.
[p. 156-7]
The
book is written in the form of a novel.
But novel it is not, in the literary sense of the word. The book is an attempt to bring Tibetan
Buddhism to the reader in the simplest way possible. It also raises some pertinent questions about
the function of religion in general. It
is no use wearing one’s religion like a badge, suggests the book plainly. The religious medals or other trappings you
wear on your body or dress won’t make you religious in the least. Such things are merely “an extension of (the)
ego, a way to present (yourself) as different or special.” [p. 48]
I
found the notion of karma quite interesting though not very convincing. If we do good, good will come back to us,
that’s the theory in short. Or to put it
a little more subtly, “as we think, so we become.” [p. 79] I’m not a religious person. But I had accepted this notion as a
hypothesis much before I read this book, and its practical ground will be my
own life. It does give me a lot of peace
and joy doing whatever good I can in my life.
That doesn’t mean I’m a saint. Far
from it, I have too many flaws and weaknesses.
It also doesn’t mean I’m doing it with the expectation that the people
to whom I do good will be good in return.
But I believe that goodness
will be my reward somewhere, somehow... It’s
a belief. A hypothesis I’ve chosen to
test out in my life. It seems to have
worked for the last few years in which I tried it out. I hope it will work in the future too. But, as I have already stated, it is not a
religious belief for me. It is my life’s
hypothesis. And the book helped me to
take a re-look at that hypothesis. The
book’s view is not much different from mine in this regard.
Would
I have bought the book were it not for a chance occurrence? No. Do
I regret buying the book? No, again. [I bought it at a fabulous discount.:)] Did I benefit much by reading it? Not really.
Nice and Very Well written review..
ReplyDeleteThank you.
DeleteImmensely glad to see you in this space again and again. thanks for the unfailing encouragement.
ReplyDeleteThanks. I'm gonna skip it, but like you said it might benefit who are new to the subject
ReplyDeletethanks for the review sir. the title was appealing but looks like I should go for another book for Tibetan Buddhism philosophy
ReplyDeleteIf you are a serious seeker of knowledge, this book is not for you.
Deletenice review. thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeletewelcome.
DeleteI too believe in karma and I too am not religious. Even so, I will try to read this book at least once :)
ReplyDeleteGood decision, Pankti. Actually every reviewer is biased by his/her interests, knowledge level, etc. Ultimately the reader is the best judge.
Delete