Book
Review
“Innovation
and originality were frowned upon and mediocrity was a virtue.” That is one of the first lessons that the
author of this book learnt about Indian Civil Services. The author joined the civil services at a
young age and if the book is any indication he did not deviate into the “risk”
of surpassing mediocrity.
Though
the book is subtitled “an autobiography,” it is more a political history of
contemporary India. The first few
chapters throw some light into the personality of the author, but the light
remains too scanty for the reader to gauge the personality and its formative
factors. What the reader gets is a hasty
tour through Bharatpur (the author’s birthplace) and the Mayo College, Ajmer,
as well as the Scindia School, Gwalior.
The author is evidently proud of his alma maters as well as his college,
St Stephen’s, Delhi.
The
rest of the book is about the author’s experiences with the various political
leaders of the country starting with Jawaharlal Nehru. The first half of the book (exactly 11
chapters out of a total of 22) is too episodic and anecdotal to be a coherent
autobiography. The author is too much
in a hurry. We understand the reason for
that haste when we come towards the last chapters: he is more interested in exonerating
himself with regard to what he calls “The Volcker Conspiracy” which implicated
him and his son in the Oil-for-Food Programme initiated in Iraq by the UN
Security Council after the ouster of Saddam Hussein from Kuwait. The events that followed the Volcker Report
led to the expulsion of Natwar Singh from the Congress Party.
Nothing
happens in the Congress Party without the knowledge and consent of Sonia
Gandhi, according to the author. Hence Ms
Gandhi becomes a target of attack in a chapter devoted to her. But Natwar Singh has much to say in
appreciation of her too. He is fairly
balanced in his appraisal of the lady. He
is not so kind towards Dr Manmohan Singh who is described as a “spineless” man.
The
second half of the book is fairly interesting because it achieves some sort of
coherence. Chapter 12 titled ‘In
Pakistan’ gives us certain insights into the way the government works (or fails
to work) in that country. The following
chapters read like political history of India though they are also not entirely
free from the episodic approach that plagues the first part.
Particularly
interesting is the chapter on the CHOGM Summit and the NAM summit that Delhi
hosted in 1983. We see certain heroes
like Yasser Arafat throwing tantrums because he was asked to address the
plenary session after the King of Jordan.
Saddam Hussein threatened to arrive with a hundred-member delegation on
a Boeing with another Boeing carrying his bullet proof cars and commandos. The Iranian delegation had serious
reservations about sitting next to the Iraqis.
The Jordanian Foreign Minister demanded a seat far away from both the
Iranians and the Iraqis. Kim Il-Sung was
paranoid as he insisted on an entire hotel for himself and his delegation with
elaborate security arrangements. The
kings and leaders of nations are quite interesting like little children when we
see them at close quarters and Natwar Singh does entertain us when he presents such
episodes.
The
book would have been much better had the author put in a little extra effort to
add more substance to it. As it is, it
remains a very superficial political history of the country from the time of
Indira Gandhi to the ascent of Narendra Modi.
Natwar Singh does not fail to praise Mr Modi on the last page while at
the same time have a dig at the previous regime: “With a commanding majority in
the Lok Sabha, the PM, to begin with will, I have no doubt, restore the image
of the country which for the past few years has been on a downward path.” After all, Mr Natwar Singh’s son, Jagat, had
switched from the Congress and become a BJP MLA from Rajasthan.
“Politics
is a blood sport where there are no friends at the top,” says the author on one
of the last pages. The books reveals the
superficiality of that game called politics where friendships are necessarily diplomatic
relationships.
Acknowledgement: I’m grateful to a student of mine who lent me his copy of the
book. I wouldn’t have cared to buy one.
You don't seem too impressed...looks like the author has provided a shallow dive at the topic.
ReplyDeleteShallow, yes, that's what it is, Shweta.
DeleteI am always quite wary about these books esp coming from a political angle. It just destroys the spirit of a book and also the freedom of a writer. And from this review I see that this guy is trying to talk about himself in the pretext of a book which is really not a great justice done to both.. and esp the reader!~
ReplyDeleteYou're right, Vinay, this book has an ulterior motive. Natwar Singh is capable of writing a far, far better autobiography. But he has written this in order to prove himself innocent and also take revenge on certain others. But, of course, he is quite mild even in the revenge.
DeleteGreat review of the book by Natwar Singh. It reveals a lot about the politics of our country.
ReplyDeletePerhaps, politics everywhere is similarly superficial. Can craze for power give us anything more than superficiality?
DeleteHmm..I'm not much into such books and it looks you're not quite happy with it... ..an honest and nice review...:-)
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed your words " if the book is any indication, he did not deviate into the “risk” of surpassing mediocrity."
ReplyDeleteI've not read the book because I think it's just Natwar Singh's sulk. After reading your review, I'm certain I will not read it.