Book Review
Tina
Sequeira’s debut collection of short stories is, as the Dedication proclaims, “an
ode to the spirit of womanhood”. Being a
woman particularly in India is no easy job. The Indian culture idealises and
idolises womanhood as pativrata, the
devoted wife. India boasts about its goddesses who are mighty to the extent of
being the invincible Durga. The country’s ancient, classical texts like the Kamasutra celebrate sexuality giving
equality to the female half of the process. Even lesbian relationships find
their dignified place in some of our temple sculptures.
The reality has always been a far cry,
however. Who were the target readers of the Kamasutra,
for instance? Who were privileged enough to enter temple complexes like the
Khajuraho? Were the majority of women in India ruled by more inhuman rubrics
and rituals like the Sati system and female infanticide? The Yajur Veda clearly
viewed the girl child as a burden and recommended rejection of the girl child: “Tasmat striyam jatam parasyanti ut pumamsam
haranti." [Hence they reject a female child when born, and take up a
male.] Manu asked a man of 30 to marry a maiden of 12 to “please” him. Pleasing
the man was the primary purpose of a woman’s existence. Pativrata!
We still find vestiges of those ancient
cultural attitudes rampant in our own times. The new custodians of morality who
emerged to wield incredible power in the last four years particularly in the
BJP-governed states give us glimpses into what the much vaunted ancient culture
really was like.
Tina Sequeira’s short stories in her
anthology titled Bhumi raises some very fascinating questions about the position
of woman in contemporary India. Each story brings to the foreground a pertinent
issue related to women though, ironically, the first one ‘Amma’ is about a man
who successfully plays the role of the mother to his motherless daughter. The
author takes penetrating looks at how the Indian women have to go the extra
mile if they want to enjoy the same liberties as their male counterparts in the
country.
Tina probes
the meaning of marriage, live-in relationships, love marriage versus arranged
marriage, feminism, female rebellion, female sexuality, social hypocrisy, patriotism,
and so on. Each of the 26 stories in this collection deals with a unique theme.
Each story is a sincere attempt on the part of a woman to understand a quintessentially
feminist issue.
Tina’s characters fascinate us. They are
very real. They belong to our own time, to our own social milieus. Some of the
characters are quite ruthless in raising their questions. The protagonist of ‘Lioness’
Share’, for instance, protests: “A Parsi man could be fucking prostitutes and
the wife could never divorce him on those grounds solely. The Parsi men could
marry outside their community and their offspring would be warmly welcomed into
the community. No questions asked. But the offspring of Parsi women (who marry
outside) were pariah.”
Tina understands the dangers of hard-core
feminism as well. ‘Juxtaposition’, for example, presents Dr Shikha the feminist
who realises at the age of 94 that the secret of her success was the same as
men’s: “Projecting their weakness and inadequacy onto the other gender,
trumpeting the cause of self-empowerment while joining the male force in their
oppression of the poor and underprivileged to usurp and maintain their power
status quo.” Dr Shikha is one of the most complex characters created by Tina.
Tina has drawn characters from diverse
backgrounds. There are divorcees enjoying themselves on a beach, a prostitute
who empowers herself by selling her adopted daughter, the mother of a little
girl raped and killed by a bunch of neo-patriots, women who outwit each other,
a young girl who dresses up as a boy in order to survive in the boy’s world,
and an honest journalist killed by the right wing fascists. It’s a wide
spectrum that deserves to be looked at.
The book is indeed a tribute to Indian
womanhood. The title story, ‘Bhumi’, is highly metaphorical. It throws eminent
light upon the woman as the eternal self-sacrifice, like the earth. The book
deserves to be read for what it is: a sincere look at the aspirations of the
Indian women.
PS. Tina’s book can be downloaded here.
Nice Article on book review of Bhumi...generally blogger avoid this kind of subject
ReplyDeletekeep sharing
Should bloggers always play it safe?
Delete