Skip to main content

The Love Song of a Secularist

The relative of the Hathras victim gather her ashes
Watch the video here

Let us go then, you and I. We’ll walk through certain half-deserted streets where some neglected truths lie awaiting redemption. We are not redeemers, you and I. We’re just observers. Observers of so-called redeemers.

You and I have endured these redeemers for the past six years. We have endured their deafening, hollow slogans. We have endured the poison they spewed into our air in the name of gods and holy cows. We have endured hatred, lynching, raping, and flagrant fraudulence that masquerades as nationalism.

We have endured endless, tedious arguments of a billion insidious intents. Isn’t it time now to take a break and ask the overwhelming question? Oh, do not ask what that question is. Let us go and make our visit.

Men in saffron come and go talking about Ram Lalla’s palatial abode coming up in Ayodhya. Yonder in Hathras is a young girl being raped by god’s defenders, the yogi’s men by caste. You know who the yogi is and what caste means in this land which they’re supposedly turning into Ram Raj. Here the hapless cries of a gangraped girl have a caste. They call it Dalit.

Everyone has a caste here, you know. And the caste determines the worth of the individual. Just to hoodwink the naïve rank and file the so-called redeemers will raise one Dalit to the President’s chair which has nothing but blinding glitter to offer. Empty glitter for one Dalit. Rape for all others.

Rape is a metaphor, you know. It is the saffron flame that rubs its back upon history’s window-panes. It is the same flame that licks our courts of justice and halls of learning making them blush in saffron shade. The same flame that rubs its back upon bills in the Parliament as if bills were toilet tissues torn off the roll on the wall.

As the flame mellows into autumn yellow, let us walk on, you and I, with faces prepared to meet the slogans that we will pass by. Sabka Saath. Beti Bhachao. Jab tak dawai nahi, tab tak dhilai nahi.

The autumn yellow turns into a burning saffron in the field yonder. You can see khaki men and a dancing flame. You can smell petrol. Women wail in the distance. The women were not even allowed to have a look at the face of their daughter raped and killed by defenders of the country’s glorious ancient civilisation.

I don’t know whether they know that women never had a place in that civilisation. Except to wail. Or to wait and serve. Or be raped and burnt.

Our sacred texts hold the formulas for everything. Formulas for plundering from others in the name of castes. Formulas to enslave the men. To rape the women. And a formula for burning the dead.

You are a formulated phrase, my friend, in this civilisation whose history goes back to millennia. We are proud of its ancestry which knew quantum mechanics and plastic surgery. We always knew how to pin you onto a wall in the form of a sprawling, wriggling formula.

The saffron flame has stopped dancing. The khaki has disappeared. There is only ash left in the field. Black ashes of a burning civilisation.

Wait. There are some boys searching for something among those ashes. Let us go, you and I, beyond smug presumptions and vain assumptions, beyond the grandeur of our ancient history, into that field where the body of a young girl was made to vanish like our redeemers do with wretchedness using financial statistics.

The boys are collecting the bones of the girl’s soul.

Don’t worry, our ancient scriptures have formulas to put those bones to eternal rest.

The yellow evening is turning dark. The saffron passion will turn darker. Let us turn back.

Now I’m sure you know what the overwhelming question is. Ask the question, my friend. Now is the time.

Don’t let dark silence fall like a shadowy spectrum between your dream and the reality, between the emotion and the response… between those neglected truths and you.

 

PS. This blog is taking part in Blogchatter’s #MyFriendAlexa campaign.

The above post is founded on T S Eliot’s classical poem, The Love Song of J Alfred Prufrock.

 

  

Comments

  1. When do you think, will this puppet game end?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Chances are dim for near future. Even if a large majority turn against the dispensation, the elections will be rigged. There may not be any election at all, perhaps. Modi has already taken over the armed forces implicitly. The future is dark. My prediction. Quite many of my predictions have come true.

      Delete
  2. I won't prefer to attach any colour to the flame of hatred, cruelty and gross injustice because in India, it is saffron whereas in our neighbouring country, it is green. All things said and done, our country is badly suffering from the dearth of those rational and kind people who support virtues like truth, justice, love and benevolence. Now the hate-mongers are freely roaming around as Bhakts of one (or more) individual(s), truth is invisible and getting justice has become akin to getting the Moon. What happened in Hathras is heart-tearing and exceedingly shameful. If this is Ram Rajya, then may Ram (himself) be kind enough to save the Indians from it. As as far as offering a Dalit the blinding glitter in the form of the President's chair is concerned, now that also is offered to a Dalit who is ready to pass five years as a yesman of the PM and not some Dalit having the calibre, competence and wisdom as possessed by Late K.R. Narayanan. When even the courts (including the SC) have become subservient to those holding the strings of political and executive power, there is indeed no hope for an ordinary person in Mera Bhaarat Mahaan.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. First of all, hatred and other evils have no particular colour. It so happened that saffron and flame have the same colour and that suited the metaphor here. You being a person familiar with literature won't need further explanation on that, I know.

      The whole post is modelled on Eliot's poem that I've mentioned at the end of the post. Hence a few lines may remain abstruse for those who are not familiar with Eliot.

      The ultimate tragedy of present India is that hate is being misunderstood as nationalism and real love [of people as well as nation - what is nation without its people, anyway?] is perceived as treason. I can feel the bhakts' blood boiling as they read this post.

      The next tragedy is that if and when we will have created that utopia called Ram Rajya we will show our real colours better by doing to the Dalits what we did to Muslims and other perceived religious enemies so far. The present treatment meted out to Dalits is just a foreshadow of what's to come.

      Delete
  3. Extremism in any religion is its hubris. That my race is the best is false pride. And yes, Hinduism is fast approaching that stage. Having said that I feel sad that just as the verdant green of nature is often ignored as the colour has become synonymous with hatred, I do pray that an orange sunset or a rich fruit may not meet the same fate as the meadows. For as they say in Hindi, gehun ke saath ghun bhi pis jaata hai. We will then have another race of people shouting for their rights and claiming innocence, with nobody to trust them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, so many good colours have acquired sinister connotations because of religious terrorism. The world has become a worse place for lots of people because of this. Sadly India has joined that gang of terrorists.

      Delete
  4. What's happening in this country is heartbreaking. Pluralism and secularism have fallen by the wayside, evil is being perpetuated in the name of God, and people have put on blinders and sing only praises to a man who is dividing, selling, and ruining this country. I hope we awake from our slumber before it is too late.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Too many people seem to believe that something good is happening. Hatred has its own charms. I too hope with you for a better India.

      Delete
  5. When I first read George Orwells dystopian novel,1984, I had felt very scared. But now we are living in the dystopia. And things are getting worse every day. What we are living through is beyond sad. But I believe like a dark night always gives way to daylight, even we will survive these dark days and be greeted by the bright sunlight of love, tolerance and inclusiveness.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The present Indian dystopia is a conscious creation of certain vested interests.

      Delete
  6. Such a thought provoking post in such a literary way. Yet, those who need to realize won't even acknowledge this. We are the rare breed left who think of a real secular India. Ruchi Nasa https://thevagabond.me

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. More and more criminals enter politics and make it irredeemable.

      Delete
  7. A well-written, thought provoking post! Hope soon we could have more and more educated, liberal Indians take sabbatical or a break and work in the interior areas to bring a difference.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How did this post lead you to this conclusion, Ninu? Happy to have you here.

      Delete
  8. Such a amazing post,with lots of deep words,felt it .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad to hear this. Making someone feel it is the real achievement.

      Delete
  9. Thats a beautiful narration of the truth in such a poetic form. There is so much that needs to be questioned, so much that needs to be set right.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This post provokes thinking with an expectation of a better future for humans and the country as a whole.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Adventures of Toto as a comic strip

  'The Adventures of Toto' is an amusing story by Ruskin Bond. It is prescribed as a lesson in CBSE's English course for class 9. Maggie asked her students to do a project on some of the lessons and Femi George's work is what I would like to present here. Femi converted the story into a beautiful comic strip. Her work will speak for itself and let me present it below.  Femi George Student of Carmel Public School, Vazhakulam, Kerala Similar post: The Little Girl

Coming-of-Age Poems

Lubna Shibu Book Review Title: Into the Wandering Multiverse Author: Lubna Shibu Publisher: Book Leaf , 2024 Pages: 23 Poetry serves as a profound medium for self-reflection. It offers a canvas where emotions, thoughts, and experiences are distilled into words. Writing poetry is a dive into the depths of one’s consciousness, exploring facets of the poet’s identity and feelings that are often left unspoken. Poets are introverts by nature, I think. Poetry is their way of encountering other people. I was reading Lubna Shibu’s debut anthology of poems while I had a substitution period in a section of grade eleven today at school. One student asked me if she could have a look at the book as I was moving around ensuring discipline while the students were engaged in their regular academic tasks. I gave her the book telling her that the author was a former student in this very classroom just a few years back. I watched the student reading a few poems with some amusement. Then I ask...

How to preach nonviolence

Like most government institutions in India, the Archaeological Survey of India [ASI] has also become a gigantic joke. The national surveyors of India’s famed antiquity go around finding all sorts of Hindu relics in Muslim mosques. Like a Shiv Ling [Lord Shiva’s penis] which may in reality be a rotting piece of a Mughal fountain. One of the recent discoveries of Modi’s national surveyors is that Sambhal in UP is the birthplace of Kalki, the tenth incarnation of God Vishnu. I haven’t understood yet whether Kalki was born in Sambhal at some time in India’s great antique history or Kalki is going to be born in Sambhal at some time in the imminent future. What I know is that Kalki is the final incarnation of Vishnu that is going to put an end to the present wicked Kali Yuga led by people like Modi Inc. Kalki will begin the next era, Satya Yuga, the Era of Truth. So he is yet to be born. But a year back, in Feb to be precise, Modi laid the foundation stone of a temple dedicated to Kalk...

The Little Girl

The Little Girl is a short story by Katherine Mansfield given in the class 9 English course of NCERT. Maggie gave an assignment to her students based on the story and one of her students, Athena Baby Sabu, presented a brilliant job. She converted the story into a delightful comic strip. Mansfield tells the story of Kezia who is the eponymous little girl. Kezia is scared of her father who wields a lot of control on the entire family. She is punished severely for an unwitting mistake which makes her even more scared of her father. Her grandmother is fond of her and is her emotional succour. The grandmother is away from home one day with Kezia's mother who is hospitalised. Kezia gets her usual nightmare and is terrified. There is no one at home to console her except her father from whom she does not expect any consolation. But the father rises to the occasion and lets the little girl sleep beside him that night. She rests her head on her father's chest and can feel his heart...

The Triumph of Godse

Book Discussion Nathuram Godse killed Mahatma Gandhi in order to save Hindus from emasculation. Gandhi was making Hindu men effeminate, incapable of retaliation. Revenge and violence are required of brave men, according to Godse. Gandhi stripped the Hindu men of their bravery and transmuted them into “sheep and goats,” Godse wrote in an article titled ‘Non-resisting tendency accomplished easily by animals.’ Gandhi had to die in order to salvage the manliness of the Hindu men. This argument that formed the foundation of Godse’s self-defence after Gandhi’s assassination was later modified by Narendra Modi et al as: “ Hindu khatre mein hai ,” Hindus are in danger. So Godse has reincarnated now.   Godse’s hatred of non-Hindus has now become the driving force of Hindutva in India. It arose primarily because of the hurt that Godse’s love for his religious community was hurt. His Hindu sentiments were hurt, in other words. Gandhi, Godse, and the minority question is the theme of the...