Skip to main content

Education is not a bargaining chip

Time, July 7, 2025 


“As a former undocumented immigrant, I know this fear. I have felt it. I have lived with the uncertainty of wondering whether a knock at the door meant separation from everything I loved.”

Alberto M Carvalho writes these lines in the latest volume of the Time magazine. Carvalho is the superintendent of the Los Angeles Unified School District, the second largest public school system in the USA. He wrote the Time article after seeing Donald Trump’s atrocious act of perpetrating a military-like operation on the country’s schools in the name of checking on undocumented immigrants. The result of such an operation, writes Carvalho, “is trauma, fear, and distrust – particularly in our schools, where children should feel safest.”

“Every child, regardless of citizenship, has a constitutional right to free public education,” Carvalho asserts. The school is the safest place for many children, he says; it is the only place where they feel truly safe, truly seen. When Trump’s agents create chaos on the campus, America is not becoming great again. America is destroying itself.

Carvalho himself was an undocumented immigrant. He landed in the USA, along with his parents and five siblings, in the 1980s. He worked in construction and restaurants (as a dishwasher) and was homeless for a time. But America brought him up. America educated him, gave him dreams, made him a hero. America of those days was more or less true to its commitment to help the huddled masses breathe free.

Does Trump know the inscription on the Statue of Liberty? “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, the wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”

And Trump himself is a grandson of immigrants in America. His father was born to German immigrants and his mother was an immigrant from Scotland. Who is not an immigrant in America?

Trump is a mere trader, not a statesman, and incapable of being a visionary. Traders look for economic profits. Visionaries create heroes. Create heroes, that’s what Carvalho is demanding in his Time article. And that process begins at school.

Education is not a bargaining chip, writes Carvalho. It is a birthright of every child. He demands of Trump to formulate policies “that are humane, lawful, and consistent with our values.” Instead Trump is creating fear on the campus. “The future of this country,” Carvalho goes on, “sits in our classrooms every day. And how we treat them will define who we are and what happens next in our nation.”

Give hope to children. Give them dreams. Help them become heroes, not beggars.

I was so touched by Carvalho’s article that I put up a short video on Facebook rather impulsively. Here it is if you care; it’s not much anyway. But it shows that I share Carvalho’s sentiments. I have been a teacher too all through my life. I can feel Carvalho’s emotions in my veins.

I’m concerned about what is happening to education in my own country which is currently led by a person who is not unlike Donald Trump.

Alberto M Carvalho


Comments

  1. Just transcribing from the Facebook response. Plato described the Sophists of his time, as peddlers of knowledge-ware. As you described, Trump is just real-estate agent, a trader... He cannot have anything to with education, in the true sense of the term. He is only nailing on the coffin of Education, the last nail. We have killed education... Reducing it to a toolkit of skills and technique, denuding it of its human content. Trump is only presiding over the Seshakriyalu... Laying to rest and cremation rites...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How much difference a leader can make! I have wondered time and again how America made the mistake of electing this man. Maybe, too many Americans are now regretting.

      Delete
  2. And not just the schools. ICE is raiding all sorts of places in LA, and they're using terrible tactics. The fear and anxiety is the point. They want to subdue us. These are cruel people given power to unleash terror, and they're doing it. I never wanted to live under an authoritarian government, and here we are.

    The thing is, where I'm at, it's likely that some of my students are undocumented. I don't care. And I don't want to see them taken away, either.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You know it much better than I since you're there watching it, feeling it... I feel sad that our leaders are all becoming worse and worse as time passes.

      Delete
  3. If there is one thing that should take top priority in any society, it's education. Reasons are too obvious to state. No one should mess with it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Messing with it is what today's leaders are all interested in, it seems.

      Delete
  4. From: Dawnanddew
    # 1 -- To quote from the blog: Does Trump know the inscription on the Statue of Liberty? “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, the wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!” [I Unquote]
    How humane are these words... The statue is the very soul of mankind itself. Sadly, it has just remained a statue. Just like in any other bequeathed democracy (to the posterity) that easily forgets its history of bloodshed, the US too has failed to remember the words etched on the gifted statue.

    # 2 -- To Quote from the blog: “The future of this country,” Carvalho goes on, “sits in our classrooms every day. And how we treat them will define who we are and what happens next in our nation.” [I Unquote]

    This exhortation is not just for Trump, I personally feel. The words should echo in every heart that goes to teach in a classroom - the heart that of a teacher. I could see larger meaning in these words of depth and veracity.
    Sometimes, the student population does contain a few miscreants, and they stretch your patience beyond that fails any learning from soul searching efforts sometimes. Treating them "nicely" becomes a herculean task. Hence, the words are far too disturbing for a teacher like me who is certainly a limited edition constantly striving to become an ideal teacher.

    # 3. To quote again: Give hope to children. Give them dreams. Help them become heroes, not beggars. [I Unquote]
    This is what I as a teacher want to become, striving to become. Any help?
    Thanks for the free space to express and flourish!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for such a detailed comment which actually serves to highlight some salient points in the post.

      Let me remind you that Carvalho was writing in the context of Trump's hunting-out of immigrant students and so the 'treatment' is not about what a teacher does in the class. It's what a country does to the students. Trump is trashing youngsters. India is doing the same in a different way, by sending trash down their brains.

      I love your last point. The answer is quite simple. If we want to help students, we have to be an inspiration to them. No matter how successful we are in the classroom teaching the subject, no matter how good we are with all the clerical work given to us by the school, unless the student feels us in their heart as a living pulsation, nothing will change. All the best to you. I know how sincere, how genuine a teacher you are.

      Delete
    2. Thank you, sir. In the recent CBSE Class X and XII Exam results, my results were excellent and particularly exceeding in class 12 as my Annual Performance Index (API) score stood out to be 950/1000 and 925/1000 in two different sections. This was an all-time high not only in my records but also in all APSs (139 schools). When they asked me the secret, I might have said nothing. But I echoed your words in the last para - "unless the student feels us in their heart as a living pulsation, nothing will change." True to the core.

      I made my constant presence in their school life and WhatsApp life with concern. And sometimes, I was so paranoid about their preparation like a fussy mother. I will strive to make a more positive impact this year. Already, I have fallen a few times, but my efforts will be in the direction of making only positive impact. No looking back. Thank you!

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Adventures of Toto as a comic strip

  'The Adventures of Toto' is an amusing story by Ruskin Bond. It is prescribed as a lesson in CBSE's English course for class 9. Maggie asked her students to do a project on some of the lessons and Femi George's work is what I would like to present here. Femi converted the story into a beautiful comic strip. Her work will speak for itself and let me present it below.  Femi George Student of Carmel Public School, Vazhakulam, Kerala Similar post: The Little Girl

The Little Girl

The Little Girl is a short story by Katherine Mansfield given in the class 9 English course of NCERT. Maggie gave an assignment to her students based on the story and one of her students, Athena Baby Sabu, presented a brilliant job. She converted the story into a delightful comic strip. Mansfield tells the story of Kezia who is the eponymous little girl. Kezia is scared of her father who wields a lot of control on the entire family. She is punished severely for an unwitting mistake which makes her even more scared of her father. Her grandmother is fond of her and is her emotional succour. The grandmother is away from home one day with Kezia's mother who is hospitalised. Kezia gets her usual nightmare and is terrified. There is no one at home to console her except her father from whom she does not expect any consolation. But the father rises to the occasion and lets the little girl sleep beside him that night. She rests her head on her father's chest and can feel his heart...

Two Women and Their Frustrations

Illustration by Gemini AI Nora and Millie are two unforgettable women in literature. Both are frustrated with their married life, though Nora’s frustration is a late experience. How they deal with their personal situations is worth a deep study. One redeems herself while the other destroys herself as well as her husband. Nora is the protagonist of Henrik Ibsen’s play, A Doll’s House , and Millie is her counterpart in Terence Rattigan’s play, The Browning Version . [The links take you to the respective text.] Personal frustration leads one to growth into an enlightened selfhood while it embitters the other. Nora’s story is emancipatory and Millie’s is destructive. Nora questions patriarchal oppression and liberates herself from it with equanimity, while Millie is trapped in a meaningless relationship. Since I have summarised these plays in earlier posts, now I’m moving on to a discussion on the enlightening contrasts between these two characters. If you’re interested in the plot ...

Hindutva’s Contradictions

The book I’m reading now is Whose Rama? [in Malayalam] by Sanskrit scholar and professor T S Syamkumar. I had mentioned this book in an earlier post . The basic premise of the book, as I understand from the initial pages, is that Hindutva is a Brahminical ideology that keeps the lower caste people outside its terrain. Non-Aryans are portrayed as monsters in ancient Hindu literature. The Shudras, the lowest caste, and the casteless others, are not even granted the status of humans.  Whose Rama? The August issue of The Caravan carries an article related to the inhuman treatment that the Brahmins of Etawah in Uttar Pradesh meted out to a Yadav “preacher” in the last week of June 2025. “Yadavs are traditionally ranked as a Shudra community,” says the article. They are not supposed to recite the holy texts. Mukut Mani Singh Yadav was reciting verses from the Bhagavad Gita. That was his crime. The Brahmins of the locality got the man’s head tonsured, forced him to rub his nose at t...

The Real Enemies of India

People in general are inclined to pass the blame on to others whatever the fault.  For example, we Indians love to blame the British for their alleged ‘divide-and-rule’ policy.  Did the British really divide India into Hindus and Muslims or did the Indians do it themselves?  Was there any unified entity called India in the first place before the British unified it? Having raised those questions, I’m going to commit a further sacrilege of quoting a British journalist-cum-historian.  In his magnum opus, India: a History , John Keay says that the “stock accusations of a wider Machiavellian intent to ‘divide and rule’ and to ‘stir up Hindu-Muslim animosity’” levelled against the British Raj made little sense when the freedom struggle was going on in India because there really was no unified India until the British unified it politically.  Communal divisions existed in India despite the political unification.  In fact, they existed even before the Briti...