Skip to main content

Arun Shourie on Narendra Modi


People of my generation are very familiar with the name Arun Shourie.  As editor of the Indian Express, he did a tremendously bold job of questioning Indira Gandhi in the days of the dreaded Emergency.  Later he joined the BJP and became an MP in the Rajya Sabha.  He has written a number of books which are thought-provoking.  The 75 year-old intellectual spoke to Swati Chaturvedi, author of I am a Troll, a book which exposed the BJP’s digital army which abuses and harasses people online for questioning Narendra Modi and the party.  Let me highlight some interesting points from the interview.
 
In happier times

Emergency-like situation in India

Mr Shourie thinks that the Prime Minister has created a “decentralised emergency”.  The country is run by mafia groups who terrorise those who criticise Modi or his policies.  Gau rakshaks, for example, are not motivated by “love for the cow” but the need to dominate other people.  Mr Modi’s emergency is worse than Indira Gandhi’s because the latter relied on the law machinery for imposing her will on the people while Mr Modi supports people who “act outside the law”.  People’s rights are being choked to death.  “... the Right to Information (RTI) is being choked, the Public Interest Litigation (PIL) is being denigrated unless it’s in your favour. The judiciary is being denigrated...”

Mr Modi is a bully

Mr Shourie says that like all bullies Mr Modi gets easily frightened.  When something wrong, he immediately panics and announces some populist schemes.  Like bullies, he resorts to intimidation and abuse when that suits him.  “Anybody who opposes Modi is immediately embroiled in cases – like Pradeep Sharma, the [IAS] official in Gujarat, and Teesta Setalvad. A third instrument towards the same end is all Non Governmental Organisations (NGOs) to be put in the dock and then to be intimidated and troubled.”

Mr Modi and antinationals

India has been divided into them versus us by Modi and Amit Shah.  “... if you look at Modi versus the cabinet, there is nobody, Modi and the party, there is no party – only Modi and Shah. Look at the choice of chief ministers – [Vijay] Rupani [of Gujarat], [Devendra] Fadnavis [of Maharashtra], [Manohar Lal] Khattar [in Haryana] – persons who do not have any base at all.”  Anyone who questions them is antinational and may be asked to go to Pakistan.   They might even face death threats.  Arvind Kejriwal’s allegation that Mr Modi wants to kill him is not false because Mr Modi supports those who act as his hounds and will do the hunting for him. 

You can read the whole interview HERE.



Comments

  1. nice one sir,
    i had read Arun shourie sir's THE ONLY FATHERLAND ...which is really a nice book .. and as far as mr.narendra modi's administration is concerned i remember the theory BANALITY OF EVIL as said by Hennah Brendt .. where people are blinded by ignorance and lost their ability to reason..this is what happening in india right now sir, people are blinded in the name of religion ... and those who are questioning it are branded anti national, i wish these people had read history, then they will come to know that our national movement is first fought for freedom of expression and freedom of press by the great Raja rammohan roy...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Banality of evil is a relevant concept here because we may soon arrive at a situation in which terrible crimes will be committed against particular sections of people reminding us of the pogrom which created that concept. Nationalism is the mask used here for hatred of people.

      Delete
    2. yes sir, and the world is heading to situation where every community will try to justify its crimes in the name of religion and nationalism.. Hindutva aganda which is being pushed by the present regime scares me alot sir. as a person belonging to minority community, the world scares me alot.. because the HINDUTVA which we are seeing now got nothing to do with hindus at all,what all they doing is arousing the feelings of our HINDU brothers and conquering their minds only to remain in power.. this can be understood clearly regarding beef ban .. hope some day our Hindu brothers will understand this and raise against this type of aganda which is actually degrading Hinduism..sanathana dharam as i know , is always about peace and happiness not crime and violence in the name of cow and bharat maata

      Delete
    3. The leader makes the difference. There are thousands of antisocial elements just waiting for opportunities to flaunt their skills. Now they have the right system. All they need to do is to pretend to be bhakts!

      Delete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Brilliant post, and Arun Shourie has rightly put forward reasoning into our country's current state. If only people could Un-elect Modi.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Unfortunately there's no un-electing! Let's hope certain lessons will be taught in the coming state elections.

      Delete
  4. Listening to the opinions of Arun Shourie about Narendra Modi is about Asking an imp who has been fired by the Satan as his deputy without serving an explanation. Arun Shourie today is one heck of a grumpy old man because he did not get the much expected cabinet post of Finance minister...
    So he and the old brigade will pour scathing criticism on NaMo. The only difference between them and Namo and them is this...During their heydays they practised a less virulent form of hindutva due to minority govt but today it is in full flow under modi and unfortunately they are sitting in the galleries watching it than leading from the front....

    I have read his waste of a book WORSHIPPING FALSE GODS on B.R.AMBEDKAR...where he reveals his fangs hidden by his benign smile...The book and his views on BHIM reveals his casteist, patriarchal and parochial mindset...No wonder why he did not respond to the open challenge of RAMACHANDRA GUHA for an open debate on the subject....He was nowhere to be seen. He sacrificed his journalistic ethics and professionalism in the corridors of power and became a stooge of BJP later in his career. Whatever he has said in his interview here has happened during his tenure in Vajpayee rule too....You need to read between the line....He is one unhappy OLD MAN who hates Modi SINCE he didnt get a cabinet post..
    He would have had a different view had he been the finance minister of the country....he is in the team of the murali manohar joshis and the advanis...the old brigade........

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that some views of Shourie were parochial and obscurantist. However, for a fair share of his life he was more sensible than most right wingers.

      His present criticism of Modi is valid and to the point whatever the motives. After all, can we ever find any person who is purely objective?

      Delete
  5. "After all, can we ever find any person who is purely objective?"- The stage we have come to!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Adventures of Toto as a comic strip

  'The Adventures of Toto' is an amusing story by Ruskin Bond. It is prescribed as a lesson in CBSE's English course for class 9. Maggie asked her students to do a project on some of the lessons and Femi George's work is what I would like to present here. Femi converted the story into a beautiful comic strip. Her work will speak for itself and let me present it below.  Femi George Student of Carmel Public School, Vazhakulam, Kerala Similar post: The Little Girl

The Little Girl

The Little Girl is a short story by Katherine Mansfield given in the class 9 English course of NCERT. Maggie gave an assignment to her students based on the story and one of her students, Athena Baby Sabu, presented a brilliant job. She converted the story into a delightful comic strip. Mansfield tells the story of Kezia who is the eponymous little girl. Kezia is scared of her father who wields a lot of control on the entire family. She is punished severely for an unwitting mistake which makes her even more scared of her father. Her grandmother is fond of her and is her emotional succour. The grandmother is away from home one day with Kezia's mother who is hospitalised. Kezia gets her usual nightmare and is terrified. There is no one at home to console her except her father from whom she does not expect any consolation. But the father rises to the occasion and lets the little girl sleep beside him that night. She rests her head on her father's chest and can feel his heart...

The Ghost of a Banyan Tree

  Image from here Fiction Jaichander Varma could not sleep. It was past midnight and the world outside Jaichander Varma’s room was fairly quiet because he lived sufficiently far away from the city. Though that entailed a tedious journey to his work and back, Mr Varma was happy with his residence because it afforded him the luxury of peaceful and pure air. The city is good, no doubt. Especially after Mr Modi became the Prime Minister, the city was the best place with so much vikas. ‘Where’s vikas?’ Someone asked Mr Varma once. Mr Varma was offended. ‘You’re a bloody antinational mussalman who should be living in Pakistan ya kabristan,’ Mr Varma told him bluntly. Mr Varma was a proud Indian which means he was a Hindu Brahmin. He believed that all others – that is, non-Brahmins – should go to their respective countries of belonging. All Muslims should go to Pakistan and Christians to Rome (or is it Italy? Whatever. Get out of Bharat Mata, that’s all.) The lower caste Hindus co...

Emergency - then and now

  When Indira Gandhi imposed a draconian Emergency on India 50 years ago on this day (25 June), I had just completed the first train journey of my life and started an entirely different kind of life. I had just joined a seminary as what they call an ‘aspirant’. One of the notice boards of the seminary always displayed the front page of an English newspaper – The Indian Express , if I recall correctly. I was only beginning to read English publications and so the headlines about Emergency didn’t really catch my attention. Since no one discussed politics in the seminary, it took me all of six months to understand the severity of the situation in the country. When I was travelling back home for Christmas vacation, the posters on the roadsides caught my attention. That’s how I began to take note of what was happening in the name of Emergency. A 15-year-old schoolboy doesn’t really understand the demise of democracy. It took me a few years and a lot of hindsight to realise the gravit...

Goodbye, Little Ones

They were born under my care, tiny throbs of life, eyes still shut to the world. They grew up under my constant care. I changed their bed and the sheets regularly making sure they were always warm and comfortable. When one of them didn’t open her eyes after a fortnight of her birth, I rang up my cousin who is a vet and got the appropriate prescription that gave her the light of day in just two days. I watched each one of them stumble through their first steps. Today they were adopted. I personally took them to their new home, a tiny house of a family that belongs to the class that India calls BPL [Below Poverty Line]. I didn’t know them at all until I stopped my car a little away from their small house, at the nearest spot my car could possibly reach. They lived in another village altogether, some 15 km from mine. Sometimes 15 km can make a world of difference. A man who looked as old as me had come to my house in the late afternoon. “I’d like to adopt your kittens,” he said. He...