Skip to main content

Hindi and India




The President of India has approved the central government’s plan to make Hindi compulsory in CBSE and Central schools (Kendriya vidyalayas).  This is the latest of many surreptitious attempts made by the central government to impose Hindi on the entire country.  Some of the recent such attempts are asking the MPs to use Hindi in the parliament, changing all highway signs in the country into Hindi, making Hindi as the official communication language for central government offices and use of Hindi by government officers even in social media such as Facebook and Twitter.

Union minister Venkaiah Naidu does not even know that Hindi is not the national language of the country.  Probably quite many Indians do not know that Hindi is not the national language.  In fact, more than half of the country’s population have mother tongues which have little do with Hindi.  There are millions of people in the country who cannot communicate in Hindi.  How can Hindi be the common language of the country then?

English has become the world’s link language.  Even countries like Japan and China which had spurned English earlier are now teaching English vigorously in their countries so that they won’t lag behind the world.  India cannot afford to neglect English at all.  Hindi may have national pride for many Indians, especially in the regions which support BJP, but English has the universal edge.

Even BJP’s erstwhile patrons knew it.  V D Savarkar and Syama Prasad Mukherjee had British education.  Deen Dayal Upadhyaya was a student of St John’s College, Agra and did his masters in English literature.  L K Advani has spoken proudly many times about his student days at St Patrick’s school, Karachi.

Today all the prominent spokespersons of BJP converse in fluent English and they know the importance of English in the media particularly because English news channels play a prominent role in the country in shaping public opinions.  Arguably the children of all these leaders who uphold Hindi vociferously study or studied in English medium schools.

Quite a lot of India’s wealth comes from Indians working abroad especially in English speaking countries.  There are millions of youth dreaming of going abroad to seek their fortune since India cannot materialise their dreams in spite of all its boasting about development.

We should learn the required lesson from Sri Lanka which suffered terrible agony because the majority wanted to impose its language on the minority.  Our own Assam was broken up into many small states because Assamese was imposed on people who spoke various tribal languages. 

Source: MapsOfIndia
 
Language cannot be imposed on people.  Indians will learn Hindi if they find it useful in making their livelihood.  There are a few million people from South India and the Northeast living in North India and they learn Hindi because it is necessary for survival.  Even the Tamils who are bitterly opposed to Hindi when they are in Tamil Nadu learn Hindi when they choose to live in the North.  That’s how life is: practical.  And little else.

The government of India should not forget that practicality when it formulates its language policies.  It is good to have our own national language.  But it should also be practical.  Using Hindi in all official communications will put a whole lot of people from Mizoram to Kerala at a clear disadvantage.  The government will obviously deprive these people of their right to know the communications.  That’s simply not fair. 

We should also not forget that there are many languages in India such as Bengali and Tamil which have much richer history, culture and literature than Hindi.  It’s not fair to suppress such languages in the name of a national language which was originally the language of the marketplace and nothing more.

It may now be argued by lovers of Hindi that propagating Hindi does not mean suppressing other languages.  The simple practical truth is that when a language is given official ascendancy it inevitably marginalises other languages.  English has done this to a great extent in many countries.  Since English has already become the global language India cannot afford to ignore it.  But what advantage is the non-Hindi speaker going to get by learning Hindi especially if he is going to live his entire life in Kohima or Kochi?

For BJP, Hindi may have nationalist associations.  For quite a lot of other Indians, Hindi may turn out to be an unnecessary burden imposed on them.  And people may not accept burdens beyond a point.  Tolerance has its limits.

Comments

  1. You have made a lot of valid points. I think pushing Hindi will create social unrest in many states that are linguistically very distinct. Besides, Bollywood movies are doing a great job in spreading Hindi. Can a diverse country like India, follow the example to Japan or France? Both much smaller and much more homogeneous countries. I hope better sense will prevail. Let states decide which language they should teach children in their territory. Is education not state subject?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Bollywood is bringing Hindi to Indians much more effectively than the government or nationalism. Maybe the govt can subsidise Hindi movies in non-Hindi states :)

      The Central govt is unnecessarily interfering with schools. Today's newspaper says that schools cannot sell textbooks and uniforms. Why not? It is certainly a source of income for private schools. So what? Can't schools make some profit and thus provide better facilities to students and staff? Who is the govt trying to help by doing such things?

      Delete
  2. Totally agree with you5r points, situation has changed a lot.
    but i have some thoughts on it...before the reign of British there was no sign of English in our country rather the foreign visitors used to learn Sanskrit and other language to communicate and read Indian Books. The truth is India is suffering from "Identity Crisis", Indians are going abroad for better facilities in every aspect but never heard that people from foreign countries are coming here.They have developed themselves much enough to be self-dependent from language to infrastructure to language, we need to be under their shade and this is also type of "dependence" this is why i believe we are still not "Independent".

    Every country should have a national language but the
    condition of India is so critical that it cant be decided now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Those olden days were totally different. People like Max Mueller or Herman Hesse took interest in Sanskrit and scriptures because highly intelligent people were motivated by philosophy and even spirituality in those days. Today people are motivated by purely pragmatic things.

      India's diversity is such that a homogeneous culture is impossible. Imposing it would be disastrous. That's why BJP is trying to do it deviously, surreptitiously, which is also not desirable. Diversity has its charm.

      Delete
  3. I do not like to imagine a situation where after a decade all the people of this nation can understand or to some extent speak a language because of movies without knowing how to read or write. That would be horrifyingly funny. Education should always be need based and or interest based but there are things which should be taught to children for a wholesome development of their personality. And although Hindi is not our National language but it is indeed an official language and hence I do not find it a conspiracy of a particular party at imposing a language. As a union government it is their duty to spread the official language as a common indigenous language other than English.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Language learning is as funny as the movies. The more you listen, the more you learn. So my suggestion to propagate Hindi movies is valid. :)

      Horrifyingly funny world, you say. Can India be more horrifyingly funny than what it is now?

      The duty of a central govt is not spreading a language, but spreading growth of all people.

      Delete
  4. सुन्दर आलेख Tomichan जी, मुझे उम्मीद है कि कम-से-कम आप थोड़ी-बहुत हिंदी जानते होंगे नहीं तो कृपया google पर Translateकर लें। कुछ बिंदु हैं जिस पर भी विचार करना चाहिए।
    1. आप के दिए गए मानचित्र (Map) में english किसी भी राज्य की सर्व-मान्य भाषा नहीं है।
    2. मानचित्र में दिखाए गए भाषाई रंग विभिन्न जरूर है परन्तु एक पर्यटक होने के नाते मुझे किसी भी राज्य में हिंदी बोलने या वहाँ के लोगों को हिंदी समझने में कोई दिक्कत नहीं महसूस किया।
    3. सर्व-मान्य है और मुझे भी कोई गलतफहमी नहीं है की विदेशों में नौकरी हेतु english की आवश्यकता होती है परन्तु सभी देशों के लिए यह लागू नहीं है और यह भी सर्व-मान्य है कि India में नौकरी के लिए Hindi का ज्ञान होना आवश्यक है, तभी साउथ इंडिया में हिंदी विरोध के बावजूद वहाँ के युवा दिल्ली या अन्य जगहों पर हिंदी धड़ल्ले से बोलते हैं।
    4. जहाँ तक नेताओं को english बोलने की बात है तो bollywood के कलाकार खाते है हिंदी का परन्तु जब interview देना हो तो english में देते हैं. यह गुलाम मानसिकता की बात है, यदि हम english बोलेंगे तो कुलीन वर्ग में मेरी गिनती होगी।
    5. जब India में hindi सीखने में दिक्कत होगी तो आप अंदाजा लगाइए कि लोगों को english सीखने में कितनी दिक्कत आएगी।
    6. मेरे टिपण्णी का गलत अर्थ ना लगाए, मैं भी मनाता हूँ क़ि आज़ादी के इतने वर्ष बीत जाने के बाद भी हमारी कोई एक मातृभाषा नहीं हैं परन्तु होनी अवश्य चाहिए चाहे वह english ही क्यों ना हो और इसपर राजनीति या अलगाववादी सोच नहीं होनी चाहिए।

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mahoday main bahut vinamrata se kehna chahunga ki agar aap bhi gugal se Angrezi sabdo ke anuwad karke kewal Hindi bhasa ka prayog karte to hriday ko atyant prashanta hoti ki koi Hindi ki puri tarah se samman karta hai.

      Shhama Karen, Rakesh Ji, jahan tak meri jaankari hai, alp bhi ho sakti hai, Bharat desh me bahut sari matribhasayen hain parantu koi rastra bhasa nahi hai.

      Meri tippani ka galat arth na lagayen mera uddheshya aapko aahat karna nahi hai. Agar aisa hota to main apna uttar aapko Tamil me likh ke deta aur kehta ki gugal ka prayog karke anuwad kar len. Maine Devnagri ki jagah Roman lipi ka prayog jarur kiya hai par aapki angrezi ke proyog ko dekh kar aasha karta hoon ki aapko samajh aa gaya hoga.

      Dhanyawad. Aapka din mangalmay beete!

      Delete
    2. താങ്ങ്കളുടെ തമാശ എനിക്കിഷ്ട്ടമായി .

      Delete
  5. I am not for or against, but the fact is that across the length and breadth of the country (even beyond the mainland..Port Blair for instance) people comfortably understand and speak Hindi..some may pose ignorance if asked for directions but the same are receptive and interested when talked shop..no issues:)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Visit my village, Amit ji,and you won't find a single person responding to Hindi.

      Delete
  6. If Hindi had not been used as a tool to mock others, I would have welcomed the move with open heart.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right perspective. I agree. I would like to go beyond. It's not just about mocking. It's more about domineering.

      Delete
  7. Its funny that people of this country are happy to learn a foreign language and call that "pragmatic" and find it a matter of pride to say that they will not learn another language from the same country. This blind mental block against Hindi , or any language for that matter, does not help anyone. In fact, blind hatred of any kind cannot be appreciated.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So why don't you learn my language instead of ordering me to learn yours. Show me the example instead of preaching to me!

      Delete
  8. I am also against any kind of such imposition.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There's no need of Imposition if people find the language useful to them. If it's useless imposition won't work. So in any case imposition is unwarranted.

      Delete
  9. Oh I wish more people got this! As a school teacher in a CBSE school in Bangalore, I find this imposition ridiculous. We have children in the school who speak Hindi at home already having trouble with the very literary/bookish kind of language the textbooks promote. If a non-native Hindi speaker were to learn that, it'll be terribly hard, and mostly useless if they were to continue living in the south. And then here's how it'll play out - the students will not score well on the subject, CBSE will realize that very late into its imposition, the exams will be simplified till you reach a point where just about anyone can clear them, and the whole point of teaching Hindi for the sake of 'language pride' or whatever will not be met anyway.
    Conversational Hindi, the useful kind, can be acquired from movies, yea!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. CBSE has been hijacked. Hereafter don't expect any sensible decision from that board. BJP and RSS will decide what CBSE will teach. Soon they will decide what India will teach. But then there's hope. There are intelligent people still left not having sold themselves to Hindutva who will raise their voices. I hope. Hope is what's left. Otherwise become a stooge...

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Adventures of Toto as a comic strip

  'The Adventures of Toto' is an amusing story by Ruskin Bond. It is prescribed as a lesson in CBSE's English course for class 9. Maggie asked her students to do a project on some of the lessons and Femi George's work is what I would like to present here. Femi converted the story into a beautiful comic strip. Her work will speak for itself and let me present it below.  Femi George Student of Carmel Public School, Vazhakulam, Kerala Similar post: The Little Girl

Don Bosco

Don Bosco (16 Aug 1815 - 31 Jan 1888) In Catholic parlance, which flows through my veins in spite of myself, today is the Feast of Don Bosco. My life was both made and unmade by Don Bosco institutions. Any great person can make or break people because of his followers. Religious institutions are the best examples. I’m presenting below an extract from my forthcoming book titled Autumn Shadows to celebrate the Feast of Don Bosco in my own way which is obviously very different from how it is celebrated in his institutions today. Do I feel nostalgic about the Feast? Not at all. I feel relieved. That’s why this celebration. The extract follows. Don Bosco, as Saint John Bosco was popularly known, had a remarkably good system for the education of youth.   He called it ‘preventive system’.   The educators should be ever vigilant so that wrong actions are prevented before they can be committed.   Reason, religion and loving kindness are the three pillars of that syste...

Relatives and Antidepressants

One of the scenes that remain indelibly etched in my memory is from a novel of Malayalam writer O V Vijayan. Father and little son are on a walk. Father tells son, “Walk carefully, son, otherwise you may fall down.” Son: “What will happen if I fall?” Father: "Relatives will laugh.” I seldom feel comfortable with my relatives. In fact, I don’t feel comfortable in any society, but relatives make it more uneasy. The reason, as I’ve understood, is that your relatives are the last people to see any goodness in you. On the other hand, they are the first ones to discover all your faults. Whenever certain relatives visit, my knees buckle and the blood pressure shoots up. I behave quite awkwardly. They often describe my behaviour as arising from my ego, which used to be a oversized in yesteryear. I had a few such visitors the other day. The problem was particularly compounded by their informing me that they would be arriving by about 3.30 pm and actually reaching at about 7.30 pm. ...

Coffee can be bitter

The dawns of my childhood were redolent of filtered black coffee. We were woken up before the birds started singing in the lush green village landscape outside home. The sun would split the darkness of the eastern sky with its splinter of white radiance much after we children had our filtered coffee with a small lump of jaggery. Take a bite of the jaggery and then a sip of the coffee. Coffee was a ritual in our home back then. Perhaps our parents believed it would jolt our neurons awake and help us absorb our lessons before we set out on the 4-kilometre walk to school after all the morning rituals at home. After high school, when I left home for further studies at a distant place, the ritual of the morning coffee stopped. It resumed a whole decade later when I completed my graduation and took up a teaching job in Shillong. But I had lost my taste for filtered coffee by then; tea took its place. Plain tea without milk – what is known as red tea in most parts of India. Coffee ret...

The Real Enemies of India

People in general are inclined to pass the blame on to others whatever the fault.  For example, we Indians love to blame the British for their alleged ‘divide-and-rule’ policy.  Did the British really divide India into Hindus and Muslims or did the Indians do it themselves?  Was there any unified entity called India in the first place before the British unified it? Having raised those questions, I’m going to commit a further sacrilege of quoting a British journalist-cum-historian.  In his magnum opus, India: a History , John Keay says that the “stock accusations of a wider Machiavellian intent to ‘divide and rule’ and to ‘stir up Hindu-Muslim animosity’” levelled against the British Raj made little sense when the freedom struggle was going on in India because there really was no unified India until the British unified it politically.  Communal divisions existed in India despite the political unification.  In fact, they existed even before the Briti...