One purpose of religions is to keep certain sections of people under
subjugation. The easiest way of subjugating people is to give them rules and
regulations in the name of their god(s). The caste system in India is an
example. Another example is the place of women in society.
All major religions in the world have kept women under male domination.
The Bible, for instance, begins with laying on the woman the whole onus for
man’s sinfulness. Then came the various ‘fathers’ of the Church to reinforce
that male domination with their divine revelations. Saint Paul, for example, was an incorrigible male chauvinist.
Perhaps, no other religion is as misogynistic as the Catholic Church
whose holy Patriarchs have time and again denounced woman as the cause of all
human evils. Thomas Aquinas, whose philosophy and theology play a major role
even today in the formation houses of Catholic priests, viewed woman as a
“defective and misbegotten” creature born out of the defective part of the
“man’s seed”. Saint Augustine denounced women as the “cause of hideous and
involuntary erections in holy men” and prohibited women from being “educated or
enlightened in any way”. Tertullian described woman as “the gate to hell”. Even
Martin Luther, the reformer, was of the opinion that “women were made either to
be wives or prostitutes.”
All three Semitic religions have similar views of women. Islam has
mathematically established gender inequality. The Quran gives each male “the
equal of the portion of two females” when it comes to property inheritance.
While giving testimony too, two women are required to equal one man. There are
places in the holy book where a woman is likened to the man’s land which he may
use whichever way he chooses. The woman is nothing more than a piece of
property. The only women you’ll find in the Muslim heaven are the virgins kept
there for men’s enjoyment; all other women are in hell.
India’s own Hinduism is no better. Right from the Vedas, women remain
men’s objects of pleasure. Women were not to be given knowledge, property,
rights, etc. The woman has to be under the care of a man all the time: first
the father, then husband, son, or relative – in that order of preference or
possibility. Widows were always considered an inconvenient burden. They were
responsible for the death of their husbands! They were considered inauspicious.
They were encouraged to die on the funeral pyre of their husbands. If they
chose to outlive their husbands, they were treated on a par with the
untouchable people.
Our attitudes are shaped by our upbringing and religion plays a dominant
role in that. This is one of the main reasons why women find it difficult to
obtain equality in conservative societies. The solution is to alter traditions
and certain undesirable aspects of cultures even if they are religious in
origin. Changing culture and tradition is always a slow process, almost
impossible if religions are involved. But we live in a world which demands such
changes. Sooner than later, women will certainly become equal to men.
Gone are the days when men were the producers and women the reproducers.
Now women are in the production line. Soon they will be firing the shots. The
writing is on the wall if you care to read.
I'm a man. I was impressed with your writing. It's just that you take a medieval perspective in this post.
ReplyDeleteIn modern era, I see many irrelevant ancient traditions that has been abandoned by millennial generations.
Believe me, the progress of improvements in gender equality is on the right track, except in areas that were not civilized.
"except in areas that were not civilized" - I live in one such 'medieval' country where the ruler is like the ancient mythological gods.
DeleteWhich country?
DeleteIndia. Haven't you heard of our Narendra Modi?
DeleteIn Hinduism women had right to read Vedas. There were women scholars like Gargi, Maitreyi etc. Unlike Abrahamic religions, Hinduism is a set of philosophical principles. True, interpretation of Hinduism has become narrow with time. Can we blame fire for burning when it also gives light? I also think you have mixed up philosophy and financial aspects.
ReplyDeleteProduction and reproduction need not be financial all the time. Simone de Beauvoir philosophises them in her book The Second Sex.
DeleteChange is inevitable. We can already see changes. It will continue.
ReplyDeleteYes. I believe that too.
DeleteI don't care what the scriptures, the mythologies, and the ancient and middle ages writing say. I don't care what has been happening in the past. The truth is that even the past has hundreds of examples where women have been in the forefront... and yet, your post takes a strange course where it isn't the subjugation of women that is apparent but the fear in the hearts of men.
ReplyDeleteThe final paragraph is all about this fear that I have mentioned. I think women have always been the empathetic decision-maker in a family and this is still what happens. They are still the same.
You and I may not care for scripture and mythology. But too many seem to care. The present political system in the country has created the situation perhaps. Fear is due to politics.
DeleteI seriously have a lot to say but I don't know what to & where to start from.
ReplyDeleteThere's a lot going on in my mind after reading this post.
I would just say that Women have done a lot in today's century but I don't think women have got that respect / worth they must.
Thanks