What did life mean to the millions of
people who awaited their death in Hitler’s concentration camps? Any day, not
too distant, they could be gassed to death. Their bodies might end up in a corpse
factory [Kadaververwertungsanstalt]
that converted human body fat into glycerine and soap. Becoming toilet soap cannot
be the meaning of anyone’s life.
What did life
mean to Hitler himself
and his accomplices who ran the camps? Murdering millions of people cannot
render anyone’s life meaningful. Hitler saw himself as the saviour of Germany.
Eliminating the Jews was part of his messianic mission. The mission was the
meaning of life for Hitler. But what about his victims?
Viktor Frankl was one of Hitler’s
victims. His mother, wife and brother were murdered by the Nazis. Frankl
survived the horrors and brutalities of the camps and wrote the celebrated
book, Man’s Search for Meaning. Meaning is what makes life bearable even
in a concentration camp, even in the face of death. Even suffering can attain a
profound meaning provided you are willing to discover that meaning.
Meaning of life is a discovery. Your
discovery. You discover the meaning of your life. You create the meaning
of your life. Of course, you can also borrow it from someone else. From
religion, for example. There’s no harm in that. But the sense of fulfilment you
get in the end may not be as much as what your own creation would give you.
The meaning of your life is the sense
of purpose you discover in your life. It is what gives direction to your life.
It is what gifts you with wisdom. It is what makes you assert that “When we are
no longer able to change a situation, we are challenged to change ourselves.”
That is what Viktor Frankl said standing in the death row.
Frankl was fortunate enough to escape
death. He had endured much in the meanwhile. The endurance taught him some of
the profound lessons of life. One of those lessons is that “Those who have a ‘why’
to live, can bear with almost any ‘how’.” That why is your meaning of
your life.
Why am I here? Ask yourself the
question. Your answer is your meaning of your life.
Ulysses |
In one of Tennyson’s poems, the Greek
King Ulysses
is bored of his idle life in the palace with his “aged wife”. He decides to
enjoy “life to the lees” by going on yet another voyage. He had already “seen
and known” much: “cities of men, and manners, climates, councils, governments …
and drunk delight of battle with (his) peers.” That was the meaning of life for
him. Kingship does not excite him. He decides to leave the country to his son
who loves “common duties … in offices of tenderness”. Ulysses calls his
mariners, men who had travelled and struggled with him for years and years, men
who had grown old with him, and tells them that “Old age hath yet his honour
and his toil.” Before death closes everything, they should do something noble,
something that befits “men that strove with Gods.” And so Ulysses and his
sailors set off “To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield.”
That striving was Ulysses’ meaning of
life. The seeking and finding without yielding except to the ultimate fate of
death is a meaning that has excited me for years now. I describe myself as a
learner. I keep learning: from books, other people, my students, anyone,
anywhere. That is my meaning of life.
The meaning you create for your life
must leave you with a sense of fulfilment too. My learning does that to me.
When I transfer something of that learning to my students, I get an extra sense
of fulfilment. When some students tell me occasionally that I inspire them, it
is a bonus sense of fulfilment. Nothing else can match that sense: not
religion, not any readymade meaning.
Next:
Religion and Meaning
No matter how dark the outlook might be there is always a lesson life has to offer. The quest for meaning must continue no matter how outrageous life might appear to treat us. If we remember this fact in life it would be a lot easier to sail through troubled waters.
ReplyDeleteI view life as a series of lessons. My students readily agree with that definition though they are yet to go through life's inevitable agonies. There's no ecstasy without the agony. The quest has to continue.
DeleteWow. What a deep post. "Those who have a 'why' to live, can bear with almost any 'how'" This is such a simple and yet such a profound thought. We endure through everything because we have something to look forward to and work for. We believe that it'll all get better eventually. And that is the reason we continue fighting, we continue living. This reminds me of a quote from a book I just finished reading, Swimming Home by Deborah Levy - "Life is only worth living because we hope it will get better and we'll all get home safely."
ReplyDeleteThanks for adding Levy to the post. It will get better... or else, we can at least make sense of what's happening: that's what meaning is.
Deletestorytelling style of writing a blog is the best way to engage your readers
ReplyDeleteIndeed. Man is a story-making animal.
DeleteAgree the meaning should give us fulfillment and contentment.
ReplyDeleteLife is exploring, discovering, learning continuously.
Agree totally.
DeleteYou have connected all the points well with the philosophy you are propagating
DeleteThanks, Pooja.
DeleteExcellent. A deep understanding of history and classical western philosophy! A contrast is of course modern atheism grounded in science! The meaning of life is to live! And perhaps no more!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Rohit. You're right, life is to be lived, lived fully, and that's precisely the meaning of life.
DeleteReminded me of the poem that I had learnt in school! Thank you.
ReplyDeleteGlad I did that. Most welcome.
DeleteAbsolutely moving article. For firsts it was deeply touching to dig so deep and find meaning. Second I am scouting for the book to find out more. Thank you for putting this out there.
ReplyDeleteThank you. This is the 1st in a series on meaning of life. Welcome to the others too.
DeleteI have also pondered long and hard over the meaning of life. Thanks for this wonderful new perspective!
ReplyDeleteIt's not new really. There have been many western philosophers who put forth this idea earlier and in much better words.
DeleteWhat is the meaning of life? That’s too lofty a question for me - one I’ve asked many a time with no satisfactory answers. What brings me meaning and peace and joy? Now that I can answer. Is that, then, my why?
ReplyDeleteCheers!
Modern Gypsy - https://moderngypsy.in
👍
DeleteIt's really important to give a meaning to your life if any body found it the whole struggle will banished
ReplyDeletePeople do find their meanings. Religion helps, for example, as i show in the next post:
DeleteReligion and Meaning
This is very deep. Although this wHy is a dangerous question. It just makes life more coMplex I feel. Why am I here or Why am I at all???
ReplyDeleteAlbert Camus would agree with you and suggest you take life as a challenge.
DeleteIn my terms I see life like a magical world filled with new set of rules daily. I really loved the way you conveyed the meaning of life!!
ReplyDeleteIf you see each day as new and magical, your life is the richest.
DeleteThe blog seriously took me to my school days, i remember this chapter taught, even i came to know that hitler himself was a jew.
ReplyDeleteGreat way it was to convey your message good work
Hitler was never a Jew 😃
DeleteWhen you fall in darkest pit of life and crawl back, you discover the secrets of life. Fine storytelling.
ReplyDeleteThat's Pragnya from www.lifewithmypenguin.com
DeleteHi Pragnya, thanks.
DeleteMeaning to life makes it easier to live. You have explained the truth very carefully by taking real life examples.
ReplyDeleteGlad you're here.
DeleteI am sure this question is in everyone's mind, why I am here and what is the meaning of life?
ReplyDeleteAnd you have explained it very nicely some real-life examples.
Life is the discovery of 'You'.. Wow. such a beautiful lines..
ReplyDeleteHi, glad you arrived here.
DeleteWonderful and thoughtful. Appreciate the way of putting questions - why and how - giving meaning to life.
ReplyDeleteHappy to hear this.
DeleteThe meaning and purpose of temporal life is training for life eternal. For human does not generate thoughts, but many other living organisms send thoughts to him, and these thoughts are either a true and lifesaving signal or a false and destructive noise. Therefore, training is needed to distinguish thoughts that are a true and lifesaving signal from thoughts that are a false and destructive noise; in order to learn with the help of the true and lifesaving signal how to live in Eternity; in order to avoid the torment of not knowing how to live there. May thoughts in you be true, and happiness - with you!
ReplyDelete