Book
Review
Very few people can make history interesting to read. Most of our
history books are written in such dull and prosaic style that only academicians
can endure them. As a school student, I detested my history books. After
school, I never touched history books until I came across writers like William
Dalrymple. Recently I read Wendy Doniger’s Alternative
History of Hinduism and fell in love with her – her
style, I mean.
Sonia Dogra has chosen to present history in verse in her new book, Unlocked.
She has clubbed poems on historical personalities together under the heading,
‘The Famous and the Infamous’, and the latter half of the book is titled
‘Epoch-Making Episodes’. People and events make up history. What makes Sonia’s
book interesting is the fact that she has chosen some unusual aspect of history
as the subject of each of these poems.
The very first poem, for example, is about Hitler. We meet the
6-year-old Hitler, however. The abuses from his father had made the little boy
a psychological wreck. The poet asks:
If the parents of an infamous Adolf Hitler
hadn’t grievously faltered,
Do you think the course of history
could have been altered?
The poem on Mahatma Gandhi looks at certain less-known dimensions of the
great soul’s life in South Africa. Titled ‘Sergeant Major Gandhi’, the poem
shows us Gandhi leading the Natal Indian Congress and also raising the Natal
Indian Ambulance Corps. The poet hints not so subtly about the shrewdness that
guided some of Gandhi’s actions.
Cleopatra’s exquisite nose is the subject of another poem. A nose that
could cast a magic spell “On the great men of Rome / who for the queen fell”
deserves the attention of poets more than historians, and Sonia has done
justice to it.
The second half of the book is about some events in history that catch
our attention. The poet has made the collection very relevant by adding a poem “dedicated
to the history of quarantine”. The Italian words ‘quaranta giorni’ mean forty
days, she informs us. The ships that arrived at harbours in Venice were not allowed
to land before forty days as a security measure.
Hundred years ago, the Spanish Flu created a quarantine situation
similar to what’s happening now with closure of all public gatherings, schools,
entertainment houses and games. “You needed a certificate to be on the lanes,”
says the poem. “Face masks had suddenly made a quick foray / Fear and mistrust,
speculation and gossip…” fill us with a strange sense of déjà vu.
Some episodes like the one presented in the poem ‘Unit 731’ are
blood-curdling. Man’s inhumanity to man has always left trails of blood in
history making us wonder again and again whether we are indeed a noble race of
creatures.
Sonia Dogra opens certain doors wide so that we can clearly see some of
our historical deeds and misdeeds. We can be proud of ourselves sometimes. We
may need to hang our heads in shame occasionally. This book’s greatest service,
perhaps, is the interest it rouses in history. We will be left at the end with
a longing for more. Making us want more history is not a mean achievement.
My book in the series is: Great
Books for Great Thoughts
Sir I am grateful that you took out time to read and review Unlocked. To hear an academician of your stature talk about it is a privilege. Much gratitude.
ReplyDeleteBest wishes. Look forward to more works from you.
DeleteA very good review, gives an insight about the wonderful book
ReplyDeleteI came across Sonia Dogra during A to Z challenge and her verses on untold stories of Historical men and women made me fall in love with the subject of History for the first time in life! Each verse, each anecdote is a masterpiece and I wish Sonia congrautlations and all the best for future journey!
ReplyDeleteYour review of her work is so very concise and apt, Tomichan ji.
Thanks Anagha. The best thing I love about Sonia Dogra is her compassionate attitude to history. Only people good at heart can posses such compassion.
DeleteYour review touches the point the mist neglected in our country...history....as you wrote, the poems had enough strength to ariuse interest in reading history and learning it....will read her...I am only humbly to mention that there have quite a pretty flow of nicer ways of presenting history...some took analytical mode, some literary...all over the world...yes, includimg our country...yes, those are not so promoted here so mostly reside in oblivion...these books undoubtedly are valued only in alimited circle of academicians and people who love to know hishory...nice that more young people are joining them..thanks again for introducing the writer and her amazing contribution in your own interesting fair of writing...best regards
ReplyDeleteHistory cannot arouse much interest anyway except among those who want to misuse it. I'm happy that writers like Sonia Dogra bring it to the public in an interesting way.
Deletemaybe...depends
DeleteSounds so interesting! Sure to check it out. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteDo. You are such a fantastic personality that it will always be good to have your opinion.
DeleteLooks like a very interesting book from your review!
ReplyDelete