Philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer described the human
will as a “the strong blind man who carries on his shoulder the lame man who
can see.” The lame man with vision is the intellect.
The intellect is conscious and hence will take
sensible decisions. But beneath that sensible faculty lies the real driving
force of human action: the will, which may be conscious or unconscious. Schopenhauer
spoke of the will as ‘the vital force’, ‘striving’, ‘spontaneous activity’, and
‘desire’. It is the will that drives us onward in life. Most of the things that
we do are driven by the will. We may like to think that our intellect is
leading us on. Schopenhauer says that the intellect acts only like a guide who
leads his master. Will is the master.
That is why we do a lot of stupid things. The will
does not have the vision to see the whole reality. It goes by instincts and
desires, partial perceptions and fractional understanding. The philosopher says
that we want a thing not because we have reasons for wanting it. We find
reasons because we want the thing. The intellect comes to serve the master’s
needs.
Desires drive us in simpler words. And our desires are
endless. Moreover, quite many of them are no good to anyone. So we create
philosophies and theologies to give charming facades to the desires. The
intellect is happy to serve again.
Nobody is convinced by logic, however. That is why
philosophies and theologies abound, they sound great too, and yet they remain
as effete as evanescent butterflies. To convince a person of anything, you must
appeal to his self-interest, his desires – his will, in short.
Why does religion with all its dramatics and rituals
appeal to human beings though most of the drama and the rituals are absurd even
by the faintest of logic? Why does even a tinge of power sway people? Why does wealth
enchant people?
People don’t make much use of their intellect.
Character lies in the will, says Schopenhauer. Not in the intellect. Character
is the continuity of one’s sense of purpose and one’s attitudes. Purpose and
attitude belong to the will, not the intellect. Just reflect for a moment: what
helped Mahatma Gandhi to win his struggle against the British? Was it his
intellect or his will? What do we mean by Gandhi’s character: his intellect which
created thousands of pages of thought-provoking writing or his sheer grit and
will?
“Brilliant qualities of mind win admiration, but never
affection,” says the philosopher. We admire geniuses for their intellectual
prowess. But we love people for their character. The will needn’t be a monster,
in other words. A good will is profounder and may be even more reliable than a
clear mind.
Schopenhauer points out that all religions (without
any exception) promise rewards for excellences of the heart (will), but none
for the excellences of the head (intellect). The will plays such a significant role
in human life. The will can be a tyrant. And often it is a terrible one.
Religions try to keep that tyrant under control.
Without some controls, the will is sure to be a
tyrant. The will is restless in both the meanings: it does not rest and it is
never at ease. It is always on one quest or another. The intellect gets tired
and needs rest. But the will never rests, not even when you are asleep.
Even the animals and plants are driven by will. Throw
a seed somewhere and watch it grow fighting against all odds. Have you ever
watched an animal’s struggle to stay alive even when there is no trace of hope
left? They are all driven by will. The world is will, Schopenhauer asserts. That
is one reason why there is so much evil in it. The will is blind, remember.
So if we wish to reduce the evil in the world, we need
to control the will and cultivate the intellect. That is Schopenhauer’s
solution. The ordinary person is mostly will and little knowledge while the
genius is mostly knowledge and little will, the philosopher says. As long as
this condition prevails, there won’t be lasting happiness or peace.
PS. This
is powered by #BlogchatterA2Z
Previous post in this series: Violence
Tomorrow: Xenophanes’s God
Is your assertion in the last paragraph really the solution offered by Schopenhauer ? Or it's just your deductive reasoning ? In my humble opinion, the theory of Schopenhauer is a reality. All the same, it's something to be accepted at its face value, instead of a problem which is to be solved. Will overpowers all kinds of intellect and similar things and that's the origin of several problems of the world, it's a fact which can't be denied. There's no need to teach or inspire people at mass level to control their will (and it's not possible also). All the same, it is in the individual's own interest to keep his/her will in check and not override whatever is rational to do (or abstain from doing). If individuals are able to do so (even to some extent), the society and the world will automatically be benefitted by that.
ReplyDeleteIt is indeed Schopenhauer's teaching, I put it in simple words. He suggests aesthetics and moral awareness as strategies for training the mind. But he was aware of their limitations too. In the end, it is a hope that at least a few people will learn something from all this. We can't redeem the world.
DeleteIf we wish to control evil we need to control will. I had never seen will from this perspective before but now your post has me thinking.
ReplyDeleteTo convince a person of anything, you must appeal to his self-interest, his desires – his will, in short.. these lines are true and probably the cause of many problems
Deepika Sharma
That's how the world runs. Look at all effective speakers. They don't speak brainy stuff.
DeleteThe concluding para of this post makes it clearer because until this post, I hadn't seen 'will' in this light. To me, will is 'the fire in the belly'; an essential ingredient to turn ideas into reality.
ReplyDeleteI will have to read this post again to become more familiar with Schopenhauer's constructs.
So much to learn in such a short life-time:) Thank you for broadening my horizons.
Most welcome, friend. Glad to have you here. You are an added impetus now.
DeleteA very enriching post! You made me see will and intellect in a new light. Loved reading it.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad to have added something to your immense knowledge. I admire the way you present literature in your videos.
DeleteThank you for writing this enlightening article. A very valuable post for me I would say for it made me understand the will and the intellect completely in a different perspective .
ReplyDeleteSchopenhauer is an interesting philosopher.
Delete