“Whom did you lose first, yourself or me?” Draupadi
asked Yudhishthira when the latter lost her as a stake in a gamble.
Yudhishthira had lost himself first, in fact. He was not his own master when he
staked his (as well as his four brothers’) wife. Even if he had not lost that
game and even if he was the sole husband of that woman, was he her owner who
could stake her like a material possession? Is the wife a property of the
husband? Is a ruler the owner of what he rules over?
Most rulers behave as if they are the owners and
masters of their territories and people. That is one of the most common
delusions of those who wield power over others. All of us nurture some
delusions even if we don’t have any power over other people. Perhaps human life
is impossible without some delusions.
Duryodhana, the man who started the game that
eventually led to an epic war, was actually envious of his cousins, the
Pandavas. “An enemy, however tiny, whose might grows on is like an anthill that
eventually destroys a mighty tree.” Duryodhana masks his simple human envy with
great philosophy. He cloaks his envy with the rationale of self-defence even
when his father assures him wisely that there is no such danger from the
Pandavas. Duryodhana is deluding himself to mask his envy and perhaps greed too.
What is a delusion? It is a belief that is maintained in spite of data, argument,
and refutation which should reasonably be sufficient to destroy it. Duryodhana
had much wise counsel against what he was going to do. But his delusion had
blinded him. Delusions necessarily blind us. Delusions make you think that you
are the master when you are in fact the slave.
Why do we delude ourselves? “One person’s delusion may be another’s salvation,” as
the Penguin Dictionary of Psychology says. Delusions are self-defence
mechanisms. They help us to avoid certain unpleasant or painful truths about
ourselves or about issues that matter vitally to us. [Religions are the most
universal examples of delusions. They act as exceptionally effective
palliatives and panaceas. Religious delusions acts as our salvations.]
We have ingrained tendencies to shut our ears to all
major truths about our deeper selves. When we are confronted with certain
truths about ourselves, our religion and its gods, our culture, or whatever we
regard as sacrosanct, we choose to be deluded. We pretend not to
understand. We pretend to be hurt. Our sentiments which are otherwise as
sensitive as the toilet seat now become highly touchy. We would prefer to do
anything other than take in information that could save us. We would also
choose to forget inconvenient truths.
Those who wield power over others tend to make use of
delusions for a variety of purposes. Chinese novelist Chan Koonchung’s
science-fiction novel, The Fat Years, is an extraordinary illustration
of this. Published in 2009, the novel is set in 2013 and shows us how a
government keeps an entire country deluded with drugs and falsehood.
The month of February is missing from the Chinese
history of 2011 in the novel. The missing period coincides with the collapse of
the world economy and the Ascendance of the Chinese Golden Age. The people of
that country tend to forget certain things and remember certain other things.
There is selective memory, in other words. The Tiananmen Square massacre of
1989 is not in the history or people’s memory anymore. The Cultural Revolution
(1966-1976), the Great Leap Forward (1958-1962), and the Civil War (1927-1951)
are a few of the many events deleted from history and memory. Those who
remember them won’t live long. Books not in accordance with the Chinese
Communist Party’s historical discourse are banned. Fang Caodi, one of the
characters, says that “certain collective memories seemed to have been
completely swallowed up by a cosmic black hole, never to be heard of again.”
The government projects the country as the best in the
world using all available means such as the media and other propaganda. The
economy is boosted through such fraudulent means as conversion of the people’s
savings accounts to expiring vouchers, deregulation, crackdowns, supply of
counterfeit goods, misinformation, and price controls. Truth is fabricated
through expedient rewriting of history.
Nevertheless, the people are happy in the country. Not
just happy, they are buoyant. They have a sense of gratification. They are
proud to be citizens of the greatest country in the world though they have no
individuality. There is no independent thinking. The Chinese Communist Party is
“great, glorious, always correct.”
The government has a simple strategy for keeping the
people so buoyant. Small doses of Ecstasy (a drug) are added to the drinking
water supplied through pipes. There is euphoria in the country. What else do
you want?
If you think this is just a novel about some other
country, you need to examine your own delusions.
PS. This is powered by Blogchatter’s #BlogchatterA2Z Challenge.
Read the
previous chapters of this endeavour:
A for Absurdity
B for Bandwagon Effect
C for Chiquitita’s
Sorrows
Tomorrow: Ego Integrity
We often tend to spend majority of our lives in delusions- one or the other kind. The concept of selective memory is interesting. Perhaps this is an effective tool of happiness. Delete what is not pleasant and stay in delusion-great message but may or may not work positively for everyone.
ReplyDeleteI am not proposing delusions as a complete panacea. Sometimes delusions can be dangerous as shown in the novel cited.
DeleteThe leaders in our own country are delusional...blinded by power..the country doesn't feel like a democracy any more.
ReplyDeleteOurs is a democracy only in its external trappings. Where dissent is muffled there is no democracy.
DeleteDelusion and Illusions
ReplyDeleteYou set me thinking
Glad I did.
DeleteI loved the premise of the novel. It is a perfect example of rulers or people with power being able to change narratives and views.
ReplyDeleteA lot of new writers are coming up with similar themes. We are in the post-truth era.
DeleteWere Yudhikshira and duyodhana narcissists being delsional about their self-image?
ReplyDeleteEvery king is a narcissist. Only degrees vary.
DeleteVery interesting read sir... Will. Check out the book in the post. It's true that most of us (inclusive of countries...and yes not only China) do live in some or other delusional state of varying degrees.... I guess it was a vicious circle. People created delusions so that they can rule or remain rulers... And the subjects didn't object to this (whoever objected ofcourse was not allowed to) and continued to live in their delusional state because truth became too much to bear!
ReplyDeleteThe present plight of India is catastrophic. People choose to ignore it just for the sake of seeing certain sections of citizens being punished for the sins of their ancestors.
DeleteI think we currently in our democratic set up are all in the state of delusion and any mention of dissent is making the regime unhappy! What can be a better way to make everyone force into the state of delusion and eventually illusion! I loved the interesting post a lot.
ReplyDeleteWe live in post-truth world. Trump, Modi, Xi Jinping... all of them are experts in deluding people. Trump is out now.
DeleteSo acche din is a delusion or illusion? haha just finished reading the previous post and couldn't stop myself from reading this.
ReplyDeleteInteresting post, true said - Truth is fabricated through expedient rewriting of history. The fat years seems an interesting read about totalitarian state, will surely check this out.
The Fat Years is a dystopian sci-fi. It's turning out to be prophetic.
Delete