I, Me, Myself |
In his latest book, Modi’s
India, Christophe Jaffrelot identifies majoritarian inferiority complex as
the driving force of India’s ethnic nationalism. The collective ego of the
Hindus is marked by a painful lack of self-esteem engendered by the many
conquests or colonisation by people like the Mughals and the British. Coupled
with this subjugation was the dread of the declining population. The Hindu
population declined from 74.3% in 1881 to 68.2% in 1931. This obviously gave
rise to a fear that the Hindus would eventually be overrun by the others,
especially the Muslims. Though the population ceased to be a problem later with
significant increases in Hindu population (84.1%in 1951), lack of self-esteem
continued to haunt the nation’s majoritarian psyche.
V D Savarkar was
driven to describe Hindus as a “mighty race” because of this national inferiority
complex. Savarkar was not much of a Hindu. He hardly practised that religion.
He was a racist. But he inspired the religious nationalists of the country
particularly because of his hatred of Muslims. Savarkar was convinced that the
Muslims were just incapable of loving the country (the punyabhoomi of India)
because their allegiance was to the land of the Prophet as proved by the
Khilafat movement. Soon, Golwalkar added the Christians and the Congress people
to the list of India’s enemies. Any nationalist movement gains more strength
when more people are made to look like enemies.
Hedgewar’s
RSS was quick to join hands with Savarkar and Golwalkar. One of the major goals
of RSS was to drill into its members the physical strength that Hindus
supposedly lacked, says Jaffrelot. B S Moonje, Hedgewar’s mentor, was an
admirer of the Muslim virility and he started eating meat in order to acquire
that sort of virility, Jaffrelot points out.
But a
carnivorous diet may not be enough to supplant a nation’s inferiority complex.
The ghosts of the past are sure to haunt any nation that suffers from such
complexes. When Hindus today seek to demolish mosques and churches, they are actually
trying to put certain ghosts of the past to sleep. Ghosts of national shame.
But those
ghosts won’t go to sleep so easily. In fact, complexes don’t vanish unless
positive actions are taken. Assaults are never positive. They create more
problems, more complexes, more guilt. And the situation is sure to get worse.
Instead, the nation can prove their virility by building harmonious relationships
based on mutual understanding and acceptance. The weak fight, the strong build understanding
and acceptance.
India’s
tragedy is that it has a leader who suffers from more inferiority complex than
the nation itself. His craze for stylish apparel, his eagerness to hobnob with world
leaders, and his substandard mockery of his rivals are ample proof (among a lot
many others) of his irresistible complexes. A nation and a leader whose complexes
match well may not be a good mixture for laying the ghosts of the past to
sleep. That is why our ghosts are so restless.
PS. Written for Indispire Edition 413: Let bygones be bygones. Bury
the past. Tell the ghosts to sleep. Let Babur and Nehru rest in peace. Of
course, they are. We are not. Restlessness of mediocrity rules us. Yes or No? #bygonesindia
Hari OM
ReplyDeleteAn excellent submission for the prompt. That fear of population disturbance is characterised by the dreadful "Great Replacement Theory" that has pervaded US politics too. YAM xx
There seemed to be a demographic threat once. But now there is neither that nor any other threat except what the right wing imagines. It is the right wing that need treatment.
DeleteIn 1931 Aden, Burma, Pakistan and Bangladesh were part of India. Partition in 1947 led to decrease of percentage of Muslim population in India. That is why percentage of Hindu population went up in 1951.
ReplyDeleteMany do not know Hindus have persecuted Buddhists. Pushyamitra Shunga, Mihirakula, Shashanka and Adi Shankara persecuted Buddhists.
True, 1931 census had that problem and thanks for the reminder. The Hindus weren't as nonviolent as they pretend or claim to be. They were violent even towards their own lower castes.
Delete