Skip to main content

Fiction in history


One of the histories of my family, written by a cousin of mine, traces the roots of the Matheikals to one Namboothiri family that was converted to Christianity by none other than Saint Thomas, disciple of Jesus. When I pointed out to the writer that there was no clear historical evidence of Namboothiri presence in Kerala until about the 8th century CE, his answer was that available family legends formed the basis of his claim.

There are many Christians in Kerala who make similar claims: that their ancient ancestors were Namboothiris (Brahmins) converted by Thomas. There is a faint possibility of Thomas, disciple of Jesus, having come to Kerala. There was active trade between Kerala and Rome in those days. Pliny the Elder (1st century CE), Roman historian, mentions Kerala’s spices, pearls, and ivory, in his work Natural History. He was actually complaining about Rome’s loss of wealth due to its imports from India.

There are travelogues that describe trade routes between Europe and India. Periplus, for instance, highlights Muziris (today’s Kodungallur, Kerala) as a major trading port and archaeological excavations in Kodungallur prove him right. Sangam literature of Tamil dating between 300 BCE and 300 CE describe the presence of Greeks and Romans (‘Yavanas’) in South Indian ports and their trade in gold, wine, glassware, and ceramics. It is possible that Saint Thomas embarked on one of those trade ships and landed in Kerala. A possibility, of course.

But, in all probability, he didn’t convert any Namboothiri to Christianity for the simple reason that Namboothiris are thought to have landed in Kerala much later. [Please read my recent post, The irresistible mating of languages, for some linguistic sidelights on that.]

Recently, the Tamil Nadu Chief Minister, M K Stalin, offered a prize of $1 million to anyone who can decode the available Harappan script. Stalin’s contention is that the Indus Valley civilisation of Harappa and Mohenjo-daro was Dravidian and that the Dravidians were forced to flee to the South by the arrival of Aryans.

The Outlook magazine (and earlier The Caravan too) has brought out an issue dedicated to this theme. There is much evidence that justifies Stalin’s claim, as shown the magazines’ articles written by eminent scholars and academicians. It won’t be possible for me to summarise all those arguments in a short blog post.

The issue seems to have caught the fancy of a lot of publications as well as others. Today’s The New Indian Express carries a catchy headline: ‘A Reminder of the Indus Valley civilisation in Thiruvananthapuram city’. A temple in Peyad, Thiruvananthapuram, carries remnants of Harappa and Mohenjo-daro, it seems.

Let there be more excavations on this instead of only digging up Muslim mosques to find Hindu relics in North India. Stalin’s ire was aroused particularly because the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) is highly biased in its studies. For example, when the ASI, under the leadership of Amarnath Ramakrishna, discovered evidence of the Harappans having fled to Keezhadi in Tamil Nadu, the Modi government ordered a stop to the research and transferred Ramakrishna from the place. Stalin got the court to allow his state archaeology department to take over the research.

Let the research go on. After all, it’s not fair to let fiction dominate history though, more often than not, fiction is truer than history.


x

Comments

  1. Hari OM
    How often has history been rewritten, one wonders... perhaps we must take all that has gone before as a form of fiction, and know that looking forward can only be fiction... it is but the moment in which we exist that has any reality. The moment in which we can strup upon our stage... YAM xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There's much fictionality when we look back. The present keeps reshaping the past. How my memory of my childhood has evolved over the years is astounding. But when governments try to fabricate new histories using archaeologists and academics, it can be a menace

      Delete
  2. It's funny how people hang their whole identities on family stories. Sometimes these turn out to be true. But often, not.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Maybe it is time to leave the past behind and look ahead...It is going to be techie's and non-techies rather than brahmins and non-brahmins.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oh, I truly believed that was the case. The way people emphasize caste hasn’t spared Christianity either. But I once visited St. Mary’s Church in Kuravilangad, one of the oldest Christian pilgrimage centers in Kerala. Thechurch claims to have been built as early as 105 AD. It is said that Kuravilangad was the site of the first apparition of Mother Mary in India. and According to legend, she appeared before a group of children and instructed them to build a church at the spot where a miraculous spring emerged, Well i guess the story went on to classify the children as BRAHMIN children

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kuravilangad and a lot of other churches in Kerala, like Malayattoor, have dubious histories. We can't touch religious sentiments in this country. So any history becomes holy.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Adventures of Toto as a comic strip

  'The Adventures of Toto' is an amusing story by Ruskin Bond. It is prescribed as a lesson in CBSE's English course for class 9. Maggie asked her students to do a project on some of the lessons and Femi George's work is what I would like to present here. Femi converted the story into a beautiful comic strip. Her work will speak for itself and let me present it below.  Femi George Student of Carmel Public School, Vazhakulam, Kerala Similar post: The Little Girl

Missing Women of Dharmasthala

The entrance to the temple Dharmasthala:  The Shadows Behind the Sanctum Ananya Bhatt, a young medical student from Manipal, visited the Dharmasthala Temple and she never returned to her hostel. She vanished without a trace. That was in 2003. Her mother, Sujata Bhatt, a stenographer working with the CBI, rushed to the temple town in search of her daughter. Some residents told her that they had seen Ananya walking with the temple officials. The local police refused to help in any way. Soon Sujata was abducted by three men, assaulted, and rendered unconscious. She woke up months later in a hospital in Bangalore (Bengaluru). Now more than two decades later, she is back in the temple premises to find her daughter’s remains and perform her last rites. Because a former sanitation worker of the temple came to the local court a few days back with a human skeleton and the confession that he had buried countless schoolgirls in uniform and other young women in the temple premises. This ma...

Two Nuns and two questions

The nuns kept in custody  Two Catholic nuns were arrested on 25 July 2025 at Durg railway station for allegedly trafficking tribal women from Narayanpur in Chhattisgarh to Agra in UP. Today’s newspapers in Kerala have expressed their contempt of the act more vehemently than I had expected. It seems secularism has hope yet in this country. For those who are not aware of the incident, two nuns were arrested because some criminals of a depraved organisation called Bajrang Dal in Chhattisgarh chose to conclude that the nuns were committing the crime of human-trafficking. Since that charge wouldn’t stick, because the women confessed that they were going voluntarily to take up jobs with the help of the nuns in order to raise their families from miserable poverty in a country that claims to be a $5-tillion-economy, another charge was fabricated that the nuns had indulged in religious conversion. Now let us look at certain facts. Though I keep questioning the Christian churches for...

Capital Punishment is not Revenge

Govindachamy when Kerala High Court confirmed his death sentence The Bible suggests that it is better for one man to die if that death helps others to live better [ John 11: 50 ]. Forgive me for applying that to a criminal today, though Jesus made that statement in a benign theological context. A notorious and hardcore criminal has escaped prison in Kerala. Fourteen years ago he assaulted a young girl who was travelling all alone in a late evening train, going back home from her workplace. The girl jumped out of the running train to save herself from this beast. But he jumped after her and raped her. The postmortem report suggested that he raped her twice, the second being when she had already fallen unconscious. And then he killed her hitting her head with a stone. Do you think that creature is human? I wrote about this back then: A Drop of Tear For You, Soumya . The people of Kerala demanded capital punishment for this creature, the brute called Govindachamy. He is inhu...

Gods, Guns and Missionaries

Book Review Title: Gods, Guns and Missionaries: The Making of the Modern Hindu Identity Author: Manu S Pillai Publisher: Penguin Random House India, 2024 Pages: 564 (about half of which consists of Notes) There never was any monolithic religion called Hinduism. Different parts of India practised Hinduism in its own ways, with its own gods and rituals and festivals. Some of these were even mutually opposed. For example, Vamana who is a revered incarnation of Vishnu in North India becomes a villain in Kerala’s Onam legends. What has become of this protean religion of infinite variety and diversity today in the hands of its ‘missionary’ political leaders? Manu S Pillai’s book ends with V D Savarkar’s contributions to the religion with a subtle hint that it is his legacy that is driving the present version of the religion in the name of Hindutva. The last lines of the book, leaving aside the Epilogue titled ‘What is Hinduism?’, are telltale. “Life did not give Savarkar all he...