The Ministry of Other People’s Appetites


When I saw the above post on Facebook, my first thoughts were about the ban on nonvegetarian food in various parts of India every now and then. Almost every week somewhere or other nonveg food is banned. For example, sale of meat, fish and eggs was prohibited during Navratri (Sep 22 to Oct 2) in many places. The most hilarious was Odisha’s Koraput district’s ban on meat, fish and eggs on Republic Day.

What is wonderfully ambitious about India’s Right Wing is that they don’t merely want to govern the country but also want to decide what the country should eat, drink, read, watch, think, worship and, if possible, dream about. Eating, in India now, is no longer a private affair between a hungry human being and a plate of food. It has become a matter of national security, cultural preservation and divine intervention.

Soon India may have a Ministry of Food Patriotism. And that ministry will issue a National Approved Menu probably with separate columns for Hindus, Muslims, Christians, atheists and those unfortunate citizens who haven’t decided what they are.

Imagine the possibilities. A government-approved breakfast. A patriotic lunch. A dinner certified by a committee of cultural guardians.

A fisherman from Kerala, a state with 600 km of seacoast and scores of rivers, is told not to eat fish anymore. “But I have eaten fish all my life. My ancestors and my children, we all survive on fish,” the fisherman protests. “That’s precisely the problem,” says the government. “You’ve been antinational for centuries. We’re now correcting all such historical mistakes.”

The absurdity is not merely that some people want to dictate what others eat. It is that they seem to believe they have a moral entitlement to do so.

People who have no business deciding what goes into another person’s stomach have appointed themselves guardians of everybody else’s appetite. Just like those who have no ovaries make laws for those who do. Our ancient classical book of law (which many Indians now want as their Constitution) said: “The father guards her in childhood, the husband in youth, and the sons in old age; the woman is never fit for independence.” [Manu Smriti 9:3] And the masculine law book goes on to give several explicit prescriptions for menstruating women.

A democracy is not a boarding school run by a particularly irritable headmaster. Citizens are not children waiting for permission to eat. And the Constitution is certainly not a cookbook authored by people who think their grandmother’s kitchen represents the entire civilisation. India’s ancient civilisation, anyway, wasn’t averse to nonveg foods at all. Even Manu said that “there is no sin in eating meat, nor in wine, nor in sexual intercourse. Such is the natural way of living beings.” [5:56]

India is a vast country of extraordinary culinary diversity. Its food traditions have been shaped by geography, climate, trade, migration, caste, religion, poverty, prosperity and centuries of cultural exchange. Even within Hinduism, food habits differ enormously. The same country that celebrates vegetarian cuisine also has deeply rooted traditions of meat and fish consumption. Kerala, my state, alone could conduct a week-long seminar on the subject followed by an elaborate nonveg lunch. Or go to northeast and the smorgasbord becomes infinitely elaborate.


Food is part of culture, certainly. But culture is not a prison. Traditions survive because people find meaning and pleasure in them, not because a government-appointed inspector stands outside the kitchen.

Most absurdly, even the so-called majority in India are not united on food habits. There is little in common between the foods of a Kerala Hindu and his UP counterpart.

The real test of civilisation is not whether everyone eats the same food. It is whether people who eat differently can live together without wanting to police one another’s plates.

And there are a lot of other far more important things for a government to worry about: hunger, malnutrition, unemployment, education and price of onions now.

Perhaps our cultural guardians should occasionally try eating a little humility. It is nutritious, universally available and, as far as I know, not prohibited by any religious scripture.  


Buon appetito

Comments

  1. What you have said, is said well and could not have been stated better. The matter is of gravity and touching upon not only our stomachs and our tounge... But our Lives. Let there be many food revolts and rebellions, like organised beef-eating sessions, defying the culture police.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Recent Posts

Show more