Gods don’t keep property deeds
![]() |
| Illustration by ChatGPT |
A story in three parts.
Part 1
Kartik Venugopal had never been particularly
interested in history. He had studied it at university merely because he didn’t
get admission to any other course and it was customary for all young men and
some women to attend the university until they married and settled down with
some job in the locality. Politics became Kartik’s profession more because he
wasn’t quite qualified for any real job.
At 40, Kartik was one of the
promising young faces of the Rashtravadi Janata Party, RJP, which ruled India
from New Delhi. Kartik’s state of Kerala had recalcitrantly remained an
uncomfortable exception to RJP’s expanding political map. The party had not won
a single seat in the state assembly despite the charismatic Prime Minister’s
eloquent rhetoric during the campaign.
“Kerala is yet to awaken to its Hindu
identity,” Amit Sharma, top leader of RJP in Delhi, had said to Kartik during
the campaign. “We need to work on that.”
Kartik was being groomed for that
work by Amit Sharma himself.
The opportunity arrived rather
unexpectedly. Swami Rudramurthy, a popular religious guru with a considerable
following on social media, declared at a public meeting in Tamil Nadu that the
famous Velankanni Basilica had originally been a Hindu shrine. Christians, he
suggested, had appropriated it centuries ago.
The statement created a sensation,
especially since many Hindus in India were determined to capture back all the
ancient temples and shrines that were supposedly appropriated by other faiths.
TV channels invited panellists to
debate the Swami’s claim. Social media filled with maps, photographs, amateur
historians and elaborate theories about many temples which were converted into
churches or mosques.
“This is your chance,” Amit Sharma
rang up from Delhi. Kartik Venugopal understood. “Don’t let it pass.”
Kartik lost no time to arrange a
press conference. He spoke passionately about the recovery of India’s
suppressed history, the restoration of Hindu pride, and the need to investigate
religious structures that might have been built over ancient Hindu places of
worship.
Kartik focused on historical justice,
not Velankanni. He was a disciple of Amit Sharma, after all.
Kartik Venugopal appeared on the
front pages of newspapers the next day. His followers increased tenfold on
social media. Amit Sharma’s Facebook page celebrated Kartik as the new voice of
Kerala’s cultural awakening.
Kartik was pleased.
Three days later, Kartik was told by
a party member that Meera Nair, his history professor at university, had
expressed severe displeasure with what he was doing. Though Kartik was not a
serious student, he held Meera Nair in great esteem because she was one of the
greatest scholars in the university those days. It wouldn’t be easy to get on
in politics without her blessings.
When Kartik visited her in her modest
house, she was watering her garden with a hose pipe.
“I hear that you’ve become a
historian,” she said smiling.
“Not quite, ma’am. But I’m interested
in recovering our history.”
“Whose history?” Meera asked as they
entered a room full of books everywhere.
Kartik laughed. “You haven’t changed,
ma’am.”
Soon the conversation turned to
Velankanni.
“Do you think Swami Rudramurthy is
right?” Kartik asked.
Meera adjusted her spectacles. “I
have no idea,” she said.
“That is surprising coming from a
historian like you.”
“Why? Would you prefer me to invent
an answer?”
She got up, went to a bookshelf and
picked up a book. Kartik could see that it was Contested Authenticities
by Rila Mukherjee.
“History is a discipline, Kartik. It
is not a collection of stories that we select according to our present
political requirements. If somebody claims that a particular building was
originally a temple, I would ask for evidence. Archaeological remains, inscriptions,
contemporary documents, reliable records, architectural studies. And I would
examine the provenance and reliability of each.”
“But, isn’t it possible that many
ancient Hindu shrines were converted into churches?”
“Possible? Certainly. But possibility
is not proof. And even if something happened in one place, it doesn’t establish
that it happened in another.”
She paused.
“Do you know what troubles me most
about these claims? The people making them are often not interested in
discovering what happened. They have already decided what must have happened.
Then they go looking for evidence to support their conclusion.”
Kartik was silent.
Meera continued. “History is full of
uncertainties. Buildings change their uses. Communities migrate. Cultures
borrow from one another. Religious traditions absorb local customs. Sometimes
the evidence is lost. Sometimes it contradicts what we would like to believe. A
responsible historian must be prepared to say, ‘I don’t know.’”
“What about historical justice?”
“What is justice without truth,
Kartik? And truth requires patience. You cannot manufacture justice out of a
fragment of fiction that someone imagined.” She paused and said with her
characteristic deep smile. “So many churches in Europe have become pubs now.
They may change into shopping malls or multiplexes in future. Imagine a
Christian seer coming two or three centuries later, when people have become
bored of godlessness, and claiming that there was a church here earlier and
hence the mall or multiplex should be handed over to the Church. You cannot
manufacture justice this way.”
Kartik left with the feeling that he
had been given a lecture he had not asked for.
Another encounter came
unexpectedly.
[To be continued]
Go to Part 2 here

I especially like Professor Meera's explanation that history must be based on facts and evidence, not just personal beliefs or political interests. Thank you for sharing
ReplyDeleteIndia is relying heavily on fiction and skullduggery instead of facts and evidence. We call that Sanatana Dharma.
DeleteHmm... very interesting. Similar claims prevail with evidence for Taj Mahal being an ancient Shiv Temple. Truth or postruth, the new government should strike a peaceful accord by doing justice to any form of faith without victmising any. So also each religion and its people. Utopia!
ReplyDeleteIf we keep digging we'll get many relics and remnants. History keeps changing. It's up to us to decide whether we should drive our vehicle looking in the rear view mirror or ahead through the windshield.
DeleteAbsolutely! History has become fungible
ReplyDeleteOnce victors wrote history. Now politicians do that job. And there's algorithm at their perpetual service.
DeleteTruth is the first casualty.
Como ciência que é a história precisa de provas consistentes.
ReplyDeleteAbrço de amizade.
Juvenal Nunes
We're specialising in fabricating history here in India.
DeleteHari OM
ReplyDeleteExcellent start...looking forward to where this takes you (and so, us)! YAM xx
Thank you. I hope you'll like it to the end.
DeleteThank you for visit my blog - i miss translate:))
ReplyDeleteLanguage of the heart has no mistakes 😊
DeleteYes.... What is Justice, without truth?
ReplyDeleteIndia has mastered the art of manipulating everything from truth to justice.
DeleteThe title caught my attention, but Professor Meera's argument kept me reading. Buildings, communities and even beliefs change over time, and your story captures that complexity very well.
ReplyDeleteThe Velankanni controversy is raging here in Kerala's social media.
DeleteI really enjoyed the encounter between Prof.Meera and Kartik. Hopefully the plot moves in a good direction and Kartik turns out not to be an utterly stupid fellow like the others.I am excited to see the other half of the story.It is quite engaging as it depicts real problems in society.Nowadays it seems every structure is either claimed to be built over a temple or illegally constructed.The story highlights the exact kind of people who never read their scriptures or visit their holy places yet know very well how to create a ruckus.
ReplyDeleteAll the three parts of the story are already up there.
Delete